iCEBREAKER
Legendary

Activity: 2156
Merit: 1073
Crypto is the separation of Power and State.
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 07:24:28 PM |
|
I think it would have been much better if as he was leaving he wrote and communicated what he thought the long term direction should be along a variety of aspects.
The problem is Satoshi left without explicitly clear long term direction.
Nope. Satoshi is a libertarian and believes in spontaneous order, not central planning.
|
██████████ ██████████████████ ██████████████████████ ██████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████ ██████████████ ██████████████ ████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████ ██████████████████████ ██████████████████ ██████████ Monero
|
| "The difference between bad and well-developed digital cash will determine whether we have a dictatorship or a real democracy." David Chaum 1996 "Fungibility provides privacy as a side effect." Adam Back 2014
|
| | |
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 07:35:28 PM |
|
i think it's hilarious that /u/nullc has tried to stir up this conspiracy around several of the members in this thread in regards to Spinoffs.
i haven't clicked on that thread in what must be over a year now, yet we got Blockstream supporters tallying up #'s of posts as some sort of evidence. i think i'll go over there after this just to find out the last time i posted just so i can embarrass them a little more the next time they bring it up. the first time was /u/nullc when he stopped by here a month or so ago. i had no idea what he was gabbing about at the time. i've kinda lost interest in the concept altho i think Peter R had a good concept at the time. the Blockstream crowd seems to think we're gonna release a spinoff if they get their SC's or LN network up or something. TBH, i don't even understand the FUD and am not even going to bother trying to. they're just immature and must be pulling their hair out over there.
|
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 07:42:03 PM |
|
i think it's hilarious that /u/nullc has tried to stir up this conspiracy around several of the members in this thread in regards to Spinoffs.
i haven't clicked on that thread in what must be over a year now, yet we got Blockstream supporters tallying up #'s of posts as some sort of evidence. i think i'll go over there after this just to find out the last time i posted just so i can embarrass them a little more the next time they bring it up. the first time was /u/nullc when he stopped by here a month or so ago. i had no idea what he was gabbing about at the time. i've kinda lost interest in the concept altho i think Peter R had a good concept at the time. the Blockstream crowd seems to think we're gonna release a spinoff if they get their SC's or LN network up or something. TBH, i don't even understand the FUD and am not even going to bother trying to. they're just immature and must be pulling their hair out over there.
hahaha. last time i posted in the Spinoff thread was July 25, 2014. yeah! i'm really pushing it, ain't i Greg!
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 07:43:34 PM |
|
From the perspective of a Bitcoin user, every possible thing that can go wrong with Bitcoin can be categorized into one of two failure modes:- A payment you belive to be valid, isn't (double spend)
- You are unable to perform a payment that you want to perform (denial of service)
Exactly, great way to put it. +1. Justus, I've been reading some of your work and I really like your push to clearly and precisely define the cryptocurrency terms we're using. Here's what I had jotted down yesterday, which sort of jives with the two points you made above: Bitcoin is decentralized if no entity exists with the ability to costlessly double-spend or bar valid transactions from the blockchain. Thoughts? I like your approach to clearly define terms but i don't like your approach of effectively redefining decentralized as a binary term when it has been generally understood to be fuzzy. This sort of redefining of terms can easily lead to confusion or deliberate obfuscation. For example, by your definition, there being a miner or pool with 50%-1GH of the hash rate would still be considered a decentralized system, but in practice such a miner could trivially increase his hash rate or collude with any other miner and then costlessly double spend or block. Likewise, a 50%+1GH pool that attempts to block might find that some miners leave and the ability to block is lost. By your definition this would not be decentralized but in practice it would be since ability is so fragile. i prefer to view decentralization more along the lines of a continuous metric such as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shapley%2dShubik_power_indexThe entities with the highest scores not only indicate whether the system is decentralized (your usage) if <1 but also how decentralized (common usage). The approach is not perfect here since there are different kinds of votes. Pool operators control important infrastructure and have some influence but their votes are not measured directly in hash rate. Further, one can likely construct a single metric along the lines of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herfindahl_index (but not exactly that) which would characterize the presence of entities with relatively high Shapley-Shubik scores.
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 07:48:23 PM |
|
i think it's hilarious that /u/nullc has tried to stir up this conspiracy around several of the members in this thread in regards to Spinoffs.
i haven't clicked on that thread in what must be over a year now, yet we got Blockstream supporters tallying up #'s of posts as some sort of evidence. i think i'll go over there after this just to find out the last time i posted just so i can embarrass them a little more the next time they bring it up. the first time was /u/nullc when he stopped by here a month or so ago. i had no idea what he was gabbing about at the time. i've kinda lost interest in the concept altho i think Peter R had a good concept at the time. the Blockstream crowd seems to think we're gonna release a spinoff if they get their SC's or LN network up or something. TBH, i don't even understand the FUD and am not even going to bother trying to. they're just immature and must be pulling their hair out over there.
What is the context? Just their old comments critical of it, or something new?
|
|
|
|
|
rocks
Legendary

Activity: 1153
Merit: 1000
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 08:12:38 PM |
|
i think it's hilarious that /u/nullc has tried to stir up this conspiracy around several of the members in this thread in regards to Spinoffs.
i haven't clicked on that thread in what must be over a year now, yet we got Blockstream supporters tallying up #'s of posts as some sort of evidence. i think i'll go over there after this just to find out the last time i posted just so i can embarrass them a little more the next time they bring it up. the first time was /u/nullc when he stopped by here a month or so ago. i had no idea what he was gabbing about at the time. i've kinda lost interest in the concept altho i think Peter R had a good concept at the time. the Blockstream crowd seems to think we're gonna release a spinoff if they get their SC's or LN network up or something. TBH, i don't even understand the FUD and am not even going to bother trying to. they're just immature and must be pulling their hair out over there.
I think they are waking up to the fact that they have pissed off a large percentage of their user base, and by user base I do not mean reddit accounts or phone wallet users, but the other infrastructure providers who make bitcoin work. (i.e. the developers behind coinbase, bitpay, circle, wallet developers, exchanges, etc). These developers have put in a tremendous amount of time, effort and money in building toolkits around the open bitcoin protocol. They require that protocol to work. They do not want to see those investments be thrown away and forced into new off chain protocols (LN and SC) which even if they work require extensive effort to transition to (and that ignores philosophical differences). They also do not want the added risk of being forced to rely on unproven technologies for their mainstream offerings and instead favor the proven mainchain behavior. The core devs have displayed themselves as poor partners to the rest of the bitcoin infrastructure community, because they are acting as if Bitcoin is still a toy for them to play around with as they see fit. This may have been true in 2010, but it's not today. It was one thing for them to dictate fee reductions as the price rose past $10 and the $100, but it is another thing to force the entire software infrastructure off the mainchain. This community wake up is not good for them long term.
|
|
|
|
|
rocks
Legendary

Activity: 1153
Merit: 1000
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 08:25:35 PM |
|
From the perspective of a Bitcoin user, every possible thing that can go wrong with Bitcoin can be categorized into one of two failure modes:- A payment you belive to be valid, isn't (double spend)
- You are unable to perform a payment that you want to perform (denial of service)
Exactly, great way to put it. +1. Justus, I've been reading some of your work and I really like your push to clearly and precisely define the cryptocurrency terms we're using. Here's what I had jotted down yesterday, which sort of jives with the two points you made above: Bitcoin is decentralized if no entity exists with the ability to costlessly double-spend or bar valid transactions from the blockchain. Thoughts? I like your approach to clearly define terms but i don't like your approach of effectively redefining decentralized as a binary term when it has been generally understood to be fuzzy. This sort of redefining of terms can easily lead to confusion or deliberate obfuscation. For example, by your definition, there being a miner or pool with 50%-1GH of the hash rate would still be considered a decentralized system, but in practice such a miner could trivially increase his hash rate or collude with any other miner and then costlessly double spend or block. Likewise, a 50%+1GH pool that attempts to block might find that some miners leave and the ability to block is lost. By your definition this would not be decentralized but in practice it would be since ability is so fragile. i prefer to view decentralization more along the lines of a continuous metric such as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shapley%2dShubik_power_indexThe entities with the highest scores not only indicate whether the system is decentralized (your usage) if <1 but also how decentralized (common usage). The approach is not perfect here since there are different kinds of votes. Pool operators control important infrastructure and have some influence but their votes are not measured directly in hash rate. Further, one can likely construct a single metric along the lines of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herfindahl_index (but not exactly that) which would characterize the presence of entities with relatively high Shapley-Shubik scores. I like the approach, but a lot depends on how you value various metrics. For example with mining pools, how few is too few where it starts to be a problem? Is going from 30 major pools to 20 major pools a reduction in Bitcoin's decentralization? I'd argue no because as long as miners have a range of pools to choose from, they will be able to select a pool that reflects their preferences. But when does this start to become an issue and how much of an issue? i.e. Does going from 20 major pools to 10 represent a significant issue or a slight one? When does it start to become a red flag issue? 5? 3? Personally I think 10 is probably enough, 5 is problem and 3 is a real problem. But that's just opinion and we can all make our own models to support various opinions. So metrics are useful, but I think defining the objectives, as justusranvier did above, are key. The objectives at least puts a framework around what is an opinion based discussion.
|
|
|
|
|
Peter R
Legendary

Activity: 1162
Merit: 1034
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 08:28:26 PM Last edit: July 01, 2015, 08:43:44 PM by Peter R |
|
i think it's hilarious that /u/nullc has tried to stir up this conspiracy around several of the members in this thread in regards to Spinoffs.
i haven't clicked on that thread in what must be over a year now, yet we got Blockstream supporters tallying up #'s of posts as some sort of evidence. i think i'll go over there after this just to find out the last time i posted just so i can embarrass them a little more the next time they bring it up. the first time was /u/nullc when he stopped by here a month or so ago. i had no idea what he was gabbing about at the time. i've kinda lost interest in the concept altho i think Peter R had a good concept at the time. the Blockstream crowd seems to think we're gonna release a spinoff if they get their SC's or LN network up or something. TBH, i don't even understand the FUD and am not even going to bother trying to. they're just immature and must be pulling their hair out over there.
I was honored that whoever created the "stopthespinoff" account thought the concept was important enough to concoct a conspiracy theory around. A little background: I came up with the "spinoff" concept 1 when there was concern in the community that Ethereum would overtake Bitcoin; many people wanted to invest in the Ether presale "just in case." I wanted to promote the idea that the "ledger of balances" was separate from the "mechanism for updating that ledger." I wanted to explain that--even in the unlikely case that the Ethereum tech was superior--there was still no reason to switch ledgers as well. So this was my primary goal with that thread: to build a theoretical defence against an alt-coin with "superior tech." I received several PMs and other offers of support to take the project one step further and launch a "demo spinoff." However, the critical mass never quite materialized. I was busy on what I considered more important work and soon lost interest. But a few months ago now, there was a bit of a resurgence in interest for spin-offs. I considered that maybe it was indeed important enough to launch a "demo spinoff" so that people could more easily grok the concept, as ZB and chriswilmer had suggested. Adam Back had recently expressed an interest in Aethereum, and so I asked if he was interested in actually launching Aethereum with me. Perhaps this fact was relayed to Greg and others, and perhaps that is why they think there's work still being done on that project. When Greg came here a few weeks ago talking about spin-offs, I wanted to re-iterate that spin-offs aren't really about adding new features, but I was 4 glasses of wine in on a sunny Sunday afternoon  . With sidechains, I think Greg wants to bring additional functionality to bitcoin, and perhaps he thinks spinoffs are intended to do the same thing. They're not. I always viewed them more as an "academic defence" to discourage scamcoins, and, in a "worst-case/bitcoin-breaking scenario," a technique that could be used to move our current ledger to a new "ledger updating protocol," thereby minimizing the loss of funds and disruptions to Bitcoin holders. 1The idea was actually named by smooth, and it also appears that others, including thezerg, had had similar ideas in the past and that my idea was not novel--just the most widely read description of an earlier idea.
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 08:32:17 PM |
|
i think it's hilarious that /u/nullc has tried to stir up this conspiracy around several of the members in this thread in regards to Spinoffs.
i haven't clicked on that thread in what must be over a year now, yet we got Blockstream supporters tallying up #'s of posts as some sort of evidence. i think i'll go over there after this just to find out the last time i posted just so i can embarrass them a little more the next time they bring it up. the first time was /u/nullc when he stopped by here a month or so ago. i had no idea what he was gabbing about at the time. i've kinda lost interest in the concept altho i think Peter R had a good concept at the time. the Blockstream crowd seems to think we're gonna release a spinoff if they get their SC's or LN network up or something. TBH, i don't even understand the FUD and am not even going to bother trying to. they're just immature and must be pulling their hair out over there.
I think they are waking up to the fact that they have pissed off a large percentage of their user base, and by user base I do not mean reddit accounts or phone wallet users, but the other infrastructure providers who make bitcoin work. (i.e. the developers behind coinbase, bitpay, circle, wallet developers, exchanges, etc). These developers have put in a tremendous amount of time, effort and money in building toolkits around the open bitcoin protocol. They require that protocol to work. They do not want to see those investments be thrown away and forced into new off chain protocols (LN and SC) which even if they work require extensive effort to transition to (and that ignores philosophical differences). They also do not want the added risk of being forced to rely on unproven technologies for their mainstream offerings and instead favor the proven mainchain behavior. The core devs have displayed themselves as poor partners to the rest of the bitcoin infrastructure community, because they are acting as if Bitcoin is still a toy for them to play around with as they see fit. This may have been true in 2010, but it's not today. It was one thing for them to dictate fee reductions as the price rose past $10 and the $100, but it is another thing to force the entire software infrastructure off the mainchain. This community wake up is not good for them long term. Let's hope you're right because I'm not entirely sure what's going on behind back doors with these other providers. Because I certainly agree with you. Unfortunately, it doesn't seem to be getting any better and I believe a fork is necessary. This latest set of allegations in regards to spinoffs is so delusional and paranoid it'd funny if it wasn't so sad & vicious. It tries to link several posters in this thread together as having some sort of financial conflict simply because we posted in Peter's thread a number of times. Well, anyone paying attention would realize that when Peter first posted it, he cross referenced his thread here so many of us could go over and comment. So by that definition, smooth must be in on the financial conspiracy as well! Funny thing is, they must have analyzed it and see spinoffs as a threat to SC's and LN. That enough will stimulate me to revisit the concept. We're dealing with children.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 09:02:01 PM |
|
i think it's hilarious that /u/nullc has tried to stir up this conspiracy around several of the members in this thread in regards to Spinoffs.
i haven't clicked on that thread in what must be over a year now, yet we got Blockstream supporters tallying up #'s of posts as some sort of evidence. i think i'll go over there after this just to find out the last time i posted just so i can embarrass them a little more the next time they bring it up. the first time was /u/nullc when he stopped by here a month or so ago. i had no idea what he was gabbing about at the time. i've kinda lost interest in the concept altho i think Peter R had a good concept at the time. the Blockstream crowd seems to think we're gonna release a spinoff if they get their SC's or LN network up or something. TBH, i don't even understand the FUD and am not even going to bother trying to. they're just immature and must be pulling their hair out over there.
I was honored that whoever created the "stopthespinoff" account thought the concept was important enough to concoct a conspiracy theory around. A little background: I came up with the "spinoff" concept 1 when there was concern in the community that Ethereum would overtake Bitcoin; many people wanted to invest in the Ether presale "just in case." I wanted to promote the idea that the "ledger of balances" was separate from the "mechanism for updating that ledger." I wanted to explain that--even in the unlikely case that the Ethereum tech was superior--there was still no reason to switch ledgers as well. So this was my primary goal with that thread: to build a theoretical defence against an alt-coin with "superior tech." I received several PMs and other offers of support to take the project one step further and launch a "demo spinoff." However, the critical mass never quite materialized. I was busy on what I considered more important work and soon lost interest. But a few months ago now, there was a bit of a resurgence in interest for spin-offs. I considered that maybe it was indeed important enough to launch a "demo spinoff" so that people could more easily grok the concept, as ZB and chriswilmer had suggested. Adam Back had recently expressed an interest in Aethereum, and so I asked if he was interested in actually launching Aethereum with me. Perhaps this fact was relayed to Greg and others, and perhaps that is why they think there's work still being done on that project. When Greg came here a few weeks ago talking about spin-offs, I wanted to re-iterate that spin-offs aren't really about adding new features, but I was 4 glasses of wine in on a sunny Sunday afternoon  . With sidechains, I think Greg wants to bring additional functionality to bitcoin, and perhaps he thinks spinoffs are intended to do the same thing. They're not. I always viewed them more as an "academic defence" to discourage scamcoins, and, in a "worst-case/bitcoin-breaking scenario," a technique that could be used to move our current ledger to a new "ledger updating protocol," thereby minimizing the loss of funds and disruptions to Bitcoin holders. 1The idea was actually named by smooth, and it also appears that others, including thezerg, had had similar ideas in the past and that my idea was not novel--just the most widely read description of an earlier idea. thanks for refreshing my memory on what happened there and the sequence of events. makes perfect sense. and you should be flattered to have them pull out this nutcase conspiracy theory. there must be something there. Peter, you have always been intellectually honest and you and several others are the engineers, geeks, and dev types that i do respect and whose opinion i value. thanks for helping to always keep things in perspective.
|
|
|
|
|
justusranvier
Legendary

Activity: 1400
Merit: 1069
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 10:27:13 PM |
|
+1. Justus, I've been reading some of your work and I really like your push to clearly and precisely define the cryptocurrency terms we're using. Here's what I had jotted down yesterday, which sort of jives with the two points you made above:
Bitcoin is decentralized if no entity exists with the ability to costlessly double-spend or bar valid transactions from the blockchain.
Thoughts? I honestly think the term "decentralized" has been ruined and I'd rather avoid it as much as possible. I'd rather express Bitcoin security in terms of: - What are the adverse behaviors a user might experience?
- How does an attacker benefit from bringing about those adverse behaviors, and how much does it cost them to perform the attack?
- What actions can users take to reduce their risk?
...then express hypothetical changes to Bitcoin in terms of how they affect the answers to the following three questions.
|
|
|
|
|
rocks
Legendary

Activity: 1153
Merit: 1000
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 10:42:34 PM |
|
+1. Justus, I've been reading some of your work and I really like your push to clearly and precisely define the cryptocurrency terms we're using. Here's what I had jotted down yesterday, which sort of jives with the two points you made above:
Bitcoin is decentralized if no entity exists with the ability to costlessly double-spend or bar valid transactions from the blockchain.
Thoughts? I honestly think the term "decentralized" has been ruined and I'd rather avoid it as much as possible. I'd rather express Bitcoin security in terms of: - What are the adverse behaviors a user might experience?
- How does an attacker benefit from bringing about those adverse behaviors, and how much does it cost them to perform the attack?
- What actions can users take to reduce their risk?
...then express hypothetical changes to Bitcoin in terms of how they affect the answers to the following three questions. I think of Bitcoin security as being successful if it can guarantee the following - 1 - Are transactions irreversible - Meaning once received is the transaction immutable on the network.
- 2 - Can anyone, anywhere interact directly with the network to spend or receive funds - Meaning it is censorship resilient and people cannot have their activity suppressed (regardless of legality)
- 3 - Can individuals maintain sole control over their funds - Meaning mechanisms exist that enable people store and control BTC with zero intermediary risk
Decentralization and everything else is a means to those ends. What is so frustrating is many of the core devs positions are against these outcomes. For example: A) Artificially limited transaction volume reduces property 2 above (i.e. it limits the # of people who can interact directly with the network. B) Peter Todd's full-RBF proposal reduces property 1 above by largely eliminating the zero-confirm guarantees the P2P network provides today. C) Sidechains reduce property 1 above if they pull transaction fees off the main chain (which reduces the effort required for a miner attack)
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
July 01, 2015, 11:46:44 PM Last edit: July 01, 2015, 11:59:59 PM by TPTB_need_war |
|
Justus and rocks, I am going to address your two recent posts...but in a whitepaper. Rocks you brush off centralization due to spamming the mining network without even considering it deeply. I've developed a model of centralization which is more scientific. From the perspective of a Bitcoin user, every possible thing that can go wrong with Bitcoin can be categorized into one of two failure modes:- A payment you belive to be valid, isn't (double spend)
- You are unable to perform a payment that you want to perform (denial of service)
Users may have other requirements including but not limited to: - Anonymity of identity, linkability, traceability, and or value transferred.
- Expediency of transfer.
- Protection of store-of-value, which can include decentralized control over debasement, inability to do malfeasance which causes a run on the coins, etc.
- Protection of fungibility.
Thus you can see your piecemeal model isn't going to work. You need a more general model of decentralization. +1. Justus, I've been reading some of your work and I really like your push to clearly and precisely define the cryptocurrency terms we're using. Here's what I had jotted down yesterday, which sort of jives with the two points you made above:
Bitcoin is decentralized if no entity exists with the ability to costlessly double-spend or bar valid transactions from the blockchain.
Thoughts?
You are describing one of the effects of decentralization, but not decentralization itself.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
July 02, 2015, 12:18:43 AM Last edit: July 02, 2015, 12:28:54 AM by TPTB_need_war |
|
You fundamentally do not understand how distributed P2P networks work if you believe that.
If you broadcast two different transactions at the exact same time, then there will be disagreement among peers over which transaction was first. Some of your peers would say transaction a was first and some would say transaction b was first.
In which case you've just broken the 3rd property of well formed transactions that I listed above (i.e. accepted by all of your peers)
This is an oversimplification and thus not true if Bitcoin was decentralized. If your system is truly decentralized (meaning in Bitcoin's design even the nodes would need to be implausibly mesh networked to avoid Sybil attacks on propagation but I digress because Bitcoin is horridly fragile[1] in so many ways it is pointless to even hope it could be decentralized), then you have a myriad of nodes with widely varying bandwidth, thus there is no way that the recipient can poll all the nodes for a conflict in ordering. It becomes a probabilistic function. The reason that zero-confirmation works reasonably well in Bitcoin is because Bitcoin is increasingly not diverse from the mining perspective, i.e. it is becoming centralized by necessity. [1] There is a good reason the core devs don't want to muck too much with constants... have fun Kabooming...this way too far beyond the average pay grade here so I won't even go there...
|
|
|
|
Melbustus
Legendary

Activity: 1722
Merit: 1004
|
 |
July 02, 2015, 12:27:30 AM |
|
|
Bitcoin is the first monetary system to credibly offer perfect information to all economic participants.
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
July 02, 2015, 01:00:35 AM Last edit: July 04, 2015, 05:08:10 AM by TPTB_need_war |
|
On Sunday, Adam reminded everyone why he is basically Bitcoin's CTO. The best bit: Working from Rusty's summary and the abstract at the top of duplex micropayment paper, I presume that lighting networks are all about offloading many consecutive small transactions between a specific spender and recipient by lumping them into one Bitcoin transaction. This is an unpublished concept I also invented last year for handling real-time micropayments between a specific spender and recipient. As I have stated more than once upthread[1], this is not a general model of micropayments. It means I can only send micropayments to an entity which I am willing tie up some of my funds with over a period of time which encompasses many transactions I will do with that entity. So thus this encourages centralization, because it will require recipients aggregate other recipients and payout those other recipients offchain (e.g. Coinbase -> Coinbase payouts). Recently I discovered (what I believe to be) how to do general micropayments on a block chain and scale the block chain. So this entirely eliminates the need for Lighting networks (except perhaps in a very real-time scenario wherein the benign latency of my design would be a factor). So sorry to say, those who are putting all this effort into Lighting Networks are probably wasting their timemay see their effort applicable to Bitcoin which is I guess worthwhile while TheyBitcoin may sooneventually be superceded (subsumed) by a superior paradigm. So iCe, who is really the CTO of crypto? Who is insane again? Come on, hammer some more nails into your coffin please. | [1] | ...If I am not mistaken, the LN paradigm is only for setting up reused payment channels between a spender and a recipient, so it is inapplicable to a myriad of micropayments between all N possible participants in the system, because each setup has to go on the block chain. Thus it really isn't a general solution for micropayments, but rather a very specific solution for REAL TIME payments. I invented LN in 2014 also, and my application for it remains REAL TIME payments.
Side chains don't help you with micropayments unless you accept that micropayments will be done centralized on a special centralized SC. In other words, the decentralization of the consensus network design has to be accomplished no matter if you put it on a SC or in Bitcoin Core...
|
P.S. I don't believe any one megalomaniac can be the total CTO of crypto (and I am not asserting Adam nominated himself). This is a collaborative effort and we build on the shoulders of each other. I do believe leaders can be instrumental in that process.
|
|
|
|
OROBTC
Legendary

Activity: 3150
Merit: 2066
|
 |
July 02, 2015, 02:07:31 AM |
|
... "Paper Gold" may indeed drop to $400. The physical, held in your own possession, will likely do just fine. Silver, well, I have some doubts. The Central Banks hold no silver, just gold.Silver (and platinum & palladium) is used in industry. Silver DOES have a historical role as money, platinum and palladium do not. Platinum and palladium perhaps are for optimists (as the world economies do better, so should the platinum group metals). Silver perhaps as well. * * * Note that I do not think that silver will fall into a role again as "money". In recent hyperinflations (Yugoslavia, Zimbabwe), silver was not used in retail commerce. What did they use? Currency. Sometimes local, sometimes US$, sometimes DM. Still, if anyone likes precious metals, consider holding more than just gold. My analysis above could very well be wrong, or a bad prediction of the future. What you really want is diversification! Bitcoin counts as diversification... Perhaps another "coin" will come along and work better than BTC, I know that some here are working on it... 
|
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
July 02, 2015, 03:37:11 AM |
|
enjoying watching the debate on Reddit. no energy to participate, however.
|
|
|
|
|
|