|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 04:13:55 AM |
|
Somebody is buying a lot of bitcoins today.
I think it's at least 2 guys. Or maybe death and taxes.
|
|
|
|
gmaxwell
Staff
Legendary

Activity: 4900
Merit: 11706
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 04:40:08 AM Last edit: July 06, 2015, 04:58:44 AM by gmaxwell |
|
ok, we've all been lead to believe up to now that validation of tx's had to occur twice by full nodes. first, upon receipt. second, upon receipt of the block. this was crucial to the FUD scare tactic of decrementing [...] what am i missing?
Where I expicitly pointed out to you in many places, in excruciating detail, that this was not at all the case?? https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/39tgno/letting_miners_vote_on_the_maximum_block_size_is/cs6rek5?context=3 You seemed so happy to argue with it before, has your memory vanished now that you don't think it would be convient for you? what's interesting is that we've never seen it done to the degree it is now. we had the Mystery Miner a few years ago but he stopped it pretty quick. also, despite many upgrades added to the protocol previously, we've never had a fork as a result of SPV mining before either. what's different this time is the consistently full blocks and the fact that Wang Chun told us they create SPV blocks in response to large blocks as a defense. it seems they consider full blocks large blocks so the excessive SPV mining created last nights fork in light of BIP66 and the upgrade to 0.10.x. so in that sense, the 1MB cap is the direct cause of what is happening.
The incohearence in some of these posts is so foaming so thick that it's oozing out and making the floor slick; careful-- you might slip and mess up your future as "the LeBron James of the Bitcoin world" (as your attorney decribed you (18:30), under oath, to a federal judge as part of litigation related to your possession of 3000 BTC taken primarly from members of this forum.). As miners have created larger blocks F2Pool expirenced high orphaning (>4% according to them); they responded by adding software to mine without transfering or verifying blocks to avoid delays related to transfering and processing block data. Contrary to your claim-- the blocksize limit stems the bleeding here. Their issue is that large blocks take more time to transfer/handle and that they're falling behind as a result. Making blocks _bigger_ would not help this problem, it would do the _opposite_. If a miner wanted to avoid any processing of transaction backlog they'd simply set their minimum fee high and they'd never even mempool the large backlog. Reasonable minds can differ on the relative importance of difference considerations, but when you're falling all over yourself to describe evidence against your position as support of it-- redefining F2pools crystal clear and plain descption of "large blocks" as their source of problems with the technically inexplicable "full" that you think supports your position, it really burns up whatever credibility you had left. That you can get away with it in this thread without a loud wall of "WTF" just shows what a strange echochamber it has become.
|
|
|
|
|
lebing
Legendary

Activity: 1288
Merit: 1002
Enabling the maximal migration
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 04:44:27 AM |
|
|
Bro, do you even blockchain? -E Voorhees
|
|
|
Peter R
Legendary

Activity: 1162
Merit: 1034
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 04:49:23 AM |
|
what's interesting is that we've never seen it done to the degree it is now. we had the Mystery Miner a few years ago but he stopped it pretty quick. also, despite many upgrades added to the protocol previously, we've never had a fork as a result of SPV mining before either. what's different this time is the consistently full blocks and the fact that Wang Chun told us they create SPV blocks in response to large blocks as a defense. it seems they consider full blocks large blocks so the excessive SPV mining created last nights fork in light of BIP66 and the upgrade to 0.10.x. so in that sense, the 1MB cap is the direct cause of what is happening.
I'm trying to understand your thinking on this matter. It makes perfect sense to me that we'd see an increase in empty blocks as the average block size rises. It seems you think the frequency of empty blocks would also actually decrease if we raised the limit (assuming the rate of transactions stayed the same). Is this an accurate assessment of what you're saying? Can you explain again why you think that?
|
|
|
|
Peter R
Legendary

Activity: 1162
Merit: 1034
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 05:58:24 AM |
|
Bitcoin sits at a strange intersection of computer science, mathematics, economics and sociology, and we can all probably learn a bit from each other. Communication is hard, especially across disciplines. 
|
|
|
|
BlindMayorBitcorn
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1116
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 06:01:36 AM |
|
Bitcoin sits at a strange intersection of computer science, mathematics, economics and sociology, and we can all probably learn a bit from each other. Communication is hard, especially across disciplines.  +1 The principle of charity should always guide us.
|
Forgive my petulance and oft-times, I fear, ill-founded criticisms, and forgive me that I have, by this time, made your eyes and head ache with my long letter. But I cannot forgo hastily the pleasure and pride of thus conversing with you.
|
|
|
gmaxwell
Staff
Legendary

Activity: 4900
Merit: 11706
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 06:32:13 AM Last edit: July 06, 2015, 06:50:38 AM by gmaxwell |
|
Bitcoin sits at a strange intersection of computer science, mathematics, economics and sociology, and we can all probably learn a bit from each other. Communication is hard, especially across disciplines.
Thats quite fair and true. As an aside, today's 3 block invalid chain reorg included a 'v3' block on the invalid fork which contained a lot of transactions. Which may suggest someone is SPV mining while including transactions (something I'd pointed out was possible previously).
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 07:17:55 AM |
|
That you can get away with it in this thread without a loud wall of "WTF" just shows what a strange echochamber it has become.
Oh, there was plenty of WTF when I read his last post, and some prior to that when he was trying to make a similar argument, but it's pretty clear that he's made up his mind and no amount of WTFing is going to change it. +63
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 07:46:30 AM |
|
Questions: Why couldn't RBF be improved so that same inputs must always pay to the same outputs when txn is replaced, except that any increases in the output values (not change in output address allowed) for increasing the fee must be matched by increase inputs? Thus the buyer can no longer steal value from the merchant which already delivered the goods. Wouldn't that resolve the complaint against RBF?
And wouldn't that then remove my argument that fixed block size limit is incompatible with 0-conf txns? (my argument was first-seen must be overruled by fee per KB when block size is a scarce resource).
Ah I realized my error. The transaction could be forever replaced. Okay instead, how about designating another UXTO address that can be exclusively drawn from? Ah but that would mean only the buyer can RBF which is not fair if the seller is the one harmed (otherwise seller could steal value from buyer).
|
|
|
|
ErisDiscordia
Legendary

Activity: 1133
Merit: 1163
Imposition of ORder = Escalation of Chaos
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 08:14:31 AM |
|
Bitcoin sits at a strange intersection of computer science, mathematics, economics and sociology, and we can all probably learn a bit from each other. Communication is hard, especially across disciplines.  well said! Having an interest in most of these fields, yet considering myself an expert in none of them I try to limit my role on the forums to facilitating productive discussion. With so many big egos around it can be very difficult at times.
|
It's all bullshit. But bullshit makes the flowers grow and that's beautiful.
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 08:42:58 AM |
|
Bitcoin sits at a strange intersection of computer science, mathematics, economics and sociology, and we can all probably learn a bit from each other. Communication is hard, especially across disciplines.
Thats quite fair and true. As an aside, today's 3 block invalid chain reorg included a 'v3' block on the invalid fork which contained a lot of transactions. Which may suggest someone is SPV mining while including transactions (something I'd pointed out was possible previously). If I may ask, what were the pools involved in this reorg?
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 09:46:44 AM Last edit: July 06, 2015, 09:59:49 AM by TPTB_need_war |
|
you might slip and mess up your future as "the LeBron James of the Bitcoin world" (as your attorney decribed you (18:30), under oath, to a federal judge as part of litigation related to your possession of 3000 BTC taken primarly from members of this forum.). I listened only to the 7 minute point where judge was skewering the female attorney who is arguing for the plaintiffs against our resident Dr. Lebron alias Cypherdorc (lol, just kidding ya my BOO!). In any case, the plaintiffs will lose the case with that bonehead attorney and line of argument. If they wanted to win, they wouldn't argue that DorkyDoc didn't do adequate promotion (because there is an entire thread on this forum showing he did, and now we have a core Dev admitting he invested 100 BTC based on Dorc's thread which adds validity to his promotional value). Rather they would argue that contract was fraudulent because why would they limit themselves to an exclusive marketing arrangement when there were multitudes of others who had similar reputations on Bitcointalk.org at the time (which is provable). In other words, DonaldDorc wasn't a scarce resource and thus it was an intentional overpayment of collusion. But then the problem is HashFast (the plaintiff) would argue against themselves, so that is why they are not arguing to win the case. They've hired a female attorney to purposefully lose the case. This is a setup. I speculate I know what is happening here. Vokain and Gmax kiss your BTC goodbye. Suckers. (just joking for the dramatic effect but it also a point to everyone to be careful and responsible and also raises the question why is a core Dev speculating on scams, I would never get caught in that... my weaknesses was ... nevermind. Gmax thanks for sharing any way) P.S. Gmax you committed a category error. It doesn't matter to his case if he slobbers on the technology (and because so many people can't understand the technology including some of the readers here, the attorneys, and the judge); it only matters that he has a huge following. (my pops is former West coast Division head attorney for Exxon)
|
|
|
|
|
newb4now
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 09:59:00 AM |
|
Again I think the heart of it for me personally is that felt Monero doesn't really own anything, other than its own (perhaps smaller than Bitcoin's rather small) community and its refined implementation. In the sense that Python owns its syntax. If you create a JPython you are still helping Python. If you create a BitcoinJ, you are still helping Bitcoin. This is what I meant when I wrote the ecosystem was a "clusterfuck" (or let's say non-ideal). We had developers and communities fighting each other on the same protocol. It felt like copycoins vs. Bitcoin, except in this case none of them were the first and legitimate one.
Yes, that's what happens when you build something and try to launch it with a fraudulent 82% premine, a fake backstory, and an army of shills trying to make it appear popular and established. A clusterfuck. So that is (or more accurately was) a fair characterization, but not one of any of our making, and one that Monero has attempted (with a fair degree of success) to replace with a vibrant and successful community. I disagree with your last sentence though. Monero is indeed the first legitimate cryptonote coin, which was launched as a minimal fork for the sole reason of getting rid of the fraudulent premine. (Also worth noting that the public face of the cryptonote team welcomed and invited forks, and even released a "coin fork creation kit"; https://cryptonotestarter.org) Monero has always been a fully public open source project where everyone including the original developers has been (and continue to be) welcome to contribute. For all we know, some of the original developers (who are anonymous, as are many Monero contributing developers) have contributed. We know, for example, that during the chain fork attack last year, the cryptonote group sent a fix (though the community had already by that time developed one anyway). One of the signs of leadership is being able to get everyone working together. You can't necessarily ever get everyone working together. Nevertheless a great many people are indeed working together a year later, and that should say something about the leadership. When you count the core developers, contributing developers to the core project, people working on Monaro-related businesses such as MyMonero and Crypto-Kingdom, mining pools, various independent developers and other significant projects (such as the new Android mobile wallet) there are at least several dozen actual developers working on various aspects of it, along with many non-developers contributing in their own ways too. I will leave to others whether that constitutes good leadership, but my opinion should be fairly obvious. I find it interesting how most coins only have 1 primary developer (and often fail when/if that developer leaves) and some coins have many people developing. Did some/most of these developers come to Monero on their own? Or were they invited to Monero from existing developers whom they already new? Do you have any tips for attracting (or keeping) developers? Specifically for new coins that do not have much if any funding yet. Bitcoin I can understand as most core developers were early adopters and have a vested interest in the project. Now that bitcoin has been relatively well established (compared to all other coins) it seems that most new development is going into supporting services and infrastructure instead of bitcoin itself. Do you see that as a pattern that will be repeated with other coins (that developers who come along after a coin has been established will be more interested in building supporting services instead of working on the core itself)?
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 10:02:23 AM Last edit: July 06, 2015, 02:20:25 PM by TPTB_need_war |
|
Do you have any tips for attracting (or keeping) developers?
Yeah hire them. It helps if you are a programmer too and can talk shop with them. Presenting sexy tech helps a lot too. Helps also if you are likeable, reasonable, and demonstrate strong technical acumen. Mutual respect builds confidence. Realize there are very few people who can possess all those skills, plus marketing skills, organizational skills, etc.. Not easy to find such a leader. Monero apparently had a core group of well-heeled guys (some that are also programmers) that gelled I believe via some connection to rpietila and David but perhaps I am mistaken. Probing my memory of the threads I read back in April, perhaps it was Tacotime that was the driving force. Specifically for new coins that do not have much if any funding yet.
Nope. Get funding. Unless you are lucky to find well-heeled devs such as apparently Tacotime, fluffypony, smooth, etc.. But they don't want to corralled by someone into a project. They joined together because they had mutual respect and wanted to together address an anonymity weakness in the market. Now that bitcoin has been relatively well established (compared to all other coins) it seems that most new development is going into supporting services and infrastructure instead of bitcoin itself. Do you see that as a pattern that will be repeated with other coins (that developers who come along after a coin has been established will be more interested in building supporting services instead of working on the core itself)?
That is the big question. Critical mass is well... critical. Blockstream's pegged side chains may help that a lot. Monero appears to have its own community now and I am not following it, but for the brief moment I was reading their thread the other day, I saw others contributing a GUI. So maybe they are starting to get some traction on that. It is a big mountain to climb compared to Bitcoin's network effects.
|
|
|
|
|
newb4now
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 10:18:01 AM |
|
Do you have any tips for attracting (or keeping) developers?
Yeah hire them. It helps if you are a programmer too and can talk shop with them. Presenting sexy tech helps a lot too. Helps also if you are likeable, reasonable, and demonstrate strong technical acumen. Mutual respect builds confidence. Realize there are very few people who can possess all those skills, plus marketing skills, organizational skills, etc.. Not easy to find such a leader. Monero apparently had a core group of guys that gelled I believe via some connection to rpietila but perhaps I am mistaken. Specifically for new coins that do not have much if any funding yet.
Nope. Get funding. I think rpietila came along early in the life of Monero but after the core devs already joined the project. One if the interesting things I see in Monero is that proportionally more bitcoin early adopters are involved than I see in other alt coins. Is it because: 1. Bitcoin early adopters see Monero as a viable hedge to side chains and other potential fungibility/privacy fixes for bitcoin? or 2. Bitcoin early adopters have been around long enough to recognize obvious pump/dump clone coins lacking much innovation and are far better at avoiding them than cryptocurrency newcomers trying to find the "next bitcoin" I think we all can agree that 99+% of all altcoins will fail. How do early adopters identify coins that may be among the <1% to succeed as either a bitcoin hedge or a viable option to fill some niche that bitcoin either can/will not?
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 10:25:39 AM Last edit: July 06, 2015, 02:22:38 PM by TPTB_need_war |
|
I think rpietila came along early in the life of Monero but after the core devs already joined the project.
Yeah I jogged my memory and edited my prior post while you were writing. One if the interesting things I see in Monero is that proportionally more bitcoin early adopters are involved than I see in other alt coins.
Is it because:
1. Bitcoin early adopters see Monero as a viable hedge to side chains and other potential fungibility/privacy fixes for bitcoin?
No I think side chains weren't a reality when Monero was launched. CN is strong on chain anonymity (but again isn't also IP obfuscation, which Tor and I2P are but I personally have doubts on Tor's and probably I2P's efficacy). Strong bet to make. Adds a real feature needed by the crypto market. or
2. Bitcoin early adopters have been around long enough to recognize obvious pump/dump clone coins lacking much innovation and are far better at avoiding them than cryptocurrency newcomers trying to find the "next bitcoin"
I think we all can agree that 99+% of all altcoins will fail. How do early adopters identify coins that may be among the <1% to succeed as either a bitcoin hedge or a viable option to fill some niche that bitcoin either can/will not?
Yeah I think they are more astute. And I don't think you can protect grandmothers from mass delusions and scams, unless you regulate a market. I suspect most of the money in shitcoins is people who know they are shit and are playing the musical chairs game of the greater fool pyramid, i.e. as long is you aren't last it doesn't matter that you weren't first and that the asset has no underlying value.
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 10:28:19 AM |
|
ok, we've all been lead to believe up to now that validation of tx's had to occur twice by full nodes. first, upon receipt. second, upon receipt of the block. this was crucial to the FUD scare tactic of decrementing [...] what am i missing?
Where I expicitly pointed out to you in many places, in excruciating detail, that this was not at all the case?? https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/39tgno/letting_miners_vote_on_the_maximum_block_size_is/cs6rek5?context=3 You seemed so happy to argue with it before, has your memory vanished now that you don't think it would be convient for you? what's interesting is that we've never seen it done to the degree it is now. we had the Mystery Miner a few years ago but he stopped it pretty quick. also, despite many upgrades added to the protocol previously, we've never had a fork as a result of SPV mining before either. what's different this time is the consistently full blocks and the fact that Wang Chun told us they create SPV blocks in response to large blocks as a defense. it seems they consider full blocks large blocks so the excessive SPV mining created last nights fork in light of BIP66 and the upgrade to 0.10.x. so in that sense, the 1MB cap is the direct cause of what is happening.
The incohearence in some of these posts is so foaming so thick that it's oozing out and making the floor slick; careful-- you might slip and mess up your future as "the LeBron James of the Bitcoin world" (as your attorney decribed you (18:30), under oath, to a federal judge as part of litigation related to your possession of 3000 BTC taken primarly from members of this forum.). As miners have created larger blocks F2Pool expirenced high orphaning (>4% according to them); they responded by adding software to mine without transfering or verifying blocks to avoid delays related to transfering and processing block data. Contrary to your claim-- the blocksize limit stems the bleeding here. Their issue is that large blocks take more time to transfer/handle and that they're falling behind as a result. Making blocks _bigger_ would not help this problem, it would do the _opposite_. If a miner wanted to avoid any processing of transaction backlog they'd simply set their minimum fee high and they'd never even mempool the large backlog. Reasonable minds can differ on the relative importance of difference considerations, but when you're falling all over yourself to describe evidence against your position as support of it-- redefining F2pools crystal clear and plain descption of "large blocks" as their source of problems with the technically inexplicable "full" that you think supports your position, it really burns up whatever credibility you had left. That you can get away with it in this thread without a loud wall of "WTF" just shows what a strange echochamber it has become. 1. Why do larger mining pools have less orphans, assuming most miners even small ones are connected to the relay network? 2. Even if mining pools set higher fees, aren't the unconfirmed TX's still added to their mempools? 3. How is it that 1MB just "happened" to be the magic number at which blocks are deemed to be "large" ?
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 12:29:46 PM Last edit: July 06, 2015, 12:40:33 PM by TPTB_need_war |
|
I'm thinking about maybe making Trapqoin by Shetty One Eye.
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
July 06, 2015, 01:13:24 PM |
|
There wasn't really a single person as the driving force behind the Monero team coming together. We were all following cryptonote already for its anonymity and other interesting features and all wanted a cryptonote fork without the 82% premine. Several of us were independently studying the code and planning one. After a few more discussions on threads, PM's and IRC, the idea of a public open source project with the core team as leadership came together.
|
|
|
|
|
|