cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 04:03:15 AM |
|
all over. and it would be the same at 8MB: 
|
|
|
|
|
molecular
Donator
Legendary

Activity: 2800
Merit: 1023
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 04:28:31 AM |
|
hey, i thought the network was only capable of 2-3 tx/s? look at our peaks today. not bad:  Those are tx merely being broadcast. "being capable of" means they can get into blocks at a sustained rate. It would be cool to see that graph for transactions having 1 confirmation.
|
PGP key molecular F9B70769 fingerprint 9CDD C0D3 20F8 279F 6BE0 3F39 FC49 2362 F9B7 0769
|
|
|
Melbustus
Legendary

Activity: 1722
Merit: 1004
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 05:20:05 AM |
|
Subsidies are great if you want to get applicants who qualify, It should be called a subsidiary not a reward for good reason, the problem is there are developers who feel the economics are wrong and Bitcoin needs to be fixed, I may not be able to express why but to my understanding the mechanism seems well balanced and considered in my view, the onus is on the people who have a problem with how Bitcoin works to prove its broken, and build a better mousetrap not change this one. My position is that it would be great if we could have started Bitcoin up without a block subsidy, but since the currency has to be issued via some method, and since the only way to produce a truly optimal initial distribution would require an entity that was both omnipotent and omniscient, issuing the currency via block subsidy spread out over time is the least terrible way to do it. It's in my queue of articles that need to be written. I like Satoshi's quote on this: ... Coins have to get initially distributed somehow, and a constant rate seems like the best formula. ...
http://www.mail-archive.com/cryptography%40metzdowd.com/msg09979.htmlThe nonchalance, to me, indicates a nice trust in markets to do their job of optimizing allocation over time. But - if Bitcoin ever starts to become a serious global economic force, mainstream economists are going to flip out over the above quote, given the initial-distribution algo didn't go through some deep analysis, etc... I think it's interesting how the engineering decision of making a simple/transparent (easy to implement, thus more secure) distribution algorithm trumped any potential detailed economic complexity, presumably due to Satoshi's understanding that the market would eventually allocate the capital optimally anyways, given the transparency of the current and future supply.
|
Bitcoin is the first monetary system to credibly offer perfect information to all economic participants.
|
|
|
Carlton Banks
Legendary

Activity: 3430
Merit: 3104
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 06:24:29 AM |
|
all over. and it would be the same at 8MB:
So you've abandoned 20 MB? And Bitcoin XT? What made you change your mind?
|
Vires in numeris
|
|
|
da2ce7
Legendary

Activity: 1222
Merit: 1018
Live and Let Live
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 06:55:00 AM |
|
 While I'm moderately against just increasing the block size. (I think that we should sort out the rest of the hard engineering infrastructure so we can actually support larger blocks first). The main point is even on this forum we have nowhere near the 95%+ consensus that we need to do a hard-fork. Gavin's latest proposal is just dangerous with only needing 75% of the miners to agree. I would much prefer Bitcoin to continue to work with 1MB blocks, than be destroyed on the reckless quest for larger blocks.
|
One off NP-Hard.
|
|
|
tvbcof
Legendary

Activity: 5390
Merit: 1370
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 06:57:29 AM |
|
I like Satoshi's quote on this: ... Coins have to get initially distributed somehow, and a constant rate seems like the best formula. ...
http://www.mail-archive.com/cryptography%40metzdowd.com/msg09979.htmlThe nonchalance, to me, indicates a nice trust in markets to do their job of optimizing allocation over time. But - if Bitcoin ever starts to become a serious global economic force, mainstream economists are going to flip out over the above quote, given the initial-distribution algo didn't go through some deep analysis, etc... I think it's interesting how the engineering decision of making a simple/transparent (easy to implement, thus more secure) distribution algorithm trumped any potential detailed economic complexity, presumably due to Satoshi's understanding that the market would eventually allocate the capital optimally anyways, given the transparency of the current and future supply. One of the nice things about having a 'benevolent dictator' is that it will be much easier to make decisions about these things going forward. We already know that in the noble interest of getting a 'critical mass' in order to 'outrun regulation', it is critical to subsidize transaction costs. We also know with some reasonable certainty that one of the early attractions of Bitcoin was that people could 'make free money' with only a token effort. People like free shit. Always will. In order to spread the wealth there are two choices. - make more wealth and give it away (e.g., screw the obsolete 21 million cap thingy.) - appropriate existing or lost money and hand it out. Idea! We can be pretty sure that if/when XT takes over, coin tainting is not far behind. Why don't we use the otherwise wasted value to pass around to the masses. Maybe like a dividend to be distributed to all existing addresses. To be more fair and reduce gaming, however, it makes sense that people would need to appropriately register their true identities in order to receive the dividend though.
|
sig spam anywhere and self-moderated threads on the pol&soc board are for losers.
|
|
|
tvbcof
Legendary

Activity: 5390
Merit: 1370
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 07:08:56 AM |
|
all over. and it would be the same at 8MB:
So you've abandoned 20 MB? And Bitcoin XT? What made you change your mind? cypherdoc changed his mind because Gavin did presumably. Gavin did because it was easier to do this as quitely as possible than to try to change the laws of arithmetic. Both of them know that it's the exponential growth that is the critical element here since it is pretty certain to sink Bitcoin eventually. (Actually, cypherdoc may or may not know that or may or may not care much if he can make a buck in the interim.) Like I've been saying about {n} MB increase (and exponential growth) for the last while now: ' Watch the pea.' Of course since I like the expression and it fits a few things here in bitcoinland, so I've also been saying the same thing about UTXO size.
|
sig spam anywhere and self-moderated threads on the pol&soc board are for losers.
|
|
|
Carlton Banks
Legendary

Activity: 3430
Merit: 3104
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 07:27:22 AM |
|
The main point is even on this forum we have nowhere near the 95%+ consensus that we need to do a hard-fork.
If there's 95% consensus, there's no need for a hard fork in the sense of campaigning to leave the 1 MB chain high and dry. There's a decent amount of time to decide though, I'm in favor of getting rid of 1MB, but it's still not totally obvious which of the many ideas is best. Why is no-one proposing to build a series of test rigs to demonstrate the leading ideas for governing the block size? That would seem like the most thorough approach. Proposing a whole host of abstract ideas, and then saying "...and game theory tells us the users will respond to these extrema in these ways, the relay nodes will respond..."; that's not very convincing to me. Asking people to choose before they've observed some empirical reality isn't a very professional approach for such a fundamental design feature. For a system that is itself fundamental, it looks reckless.
|
Vires in numeris
|
|
|
Zarathustra
Legendary

Activity: 1162
Merit: 1004
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 07:55:13 AM |
|
Whether the society and its elite is national or international or both is irrelevant. Relevant is: Do you promote the society (collectivism/paternalism) or the community (anarchy, self-sufficiency).
|
|
|
|
|
Erdogan
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1005
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 08:03:22 AM |
|
This does not mean I want an artificial cap; the lower prices and the larger number of happy customers, the better chance bitcoin has to be the global money system everybody prefer. Only the physical limits of the system, as defined by nature, should exist.
There is no physical limit defined by nature, other than whatever the highest capacity node in the world can handle (which would be the only node able to keep up and therefore the network would consist of a single node). In any other configuration the capacity is defined by the lowest capacity node on the network, which is not a limit defined by nature, but by intended or unintended consequences of the protocol design. If you want the lowest capacity node to be home computers, embedded devices, etc. then the protocol has to be designed differently than if you want that lowest capacity node to be a large or very large server in a data center. Nature allows either. That limit yes, what the computer can handle. I don't care about home computers or embedded devices. There will not be only one, just like there is not only one gold miner in the world. The market will decide how many, it is impossible to compute the number needed. The least effective nodes will be those that barely give the owners the psychical advantage to cost. It is the market, we can trust it.
|
|
|
|
|
Erdogan
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1005
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 08:12:35 AM |
|
I like Satoshi's quote on this: ... Coins have to get initially distributed somehow, and a constant rate seems like the best formula. ...
http://www.mail-archive.com/cryptography%40metzdowd.com/msg09979.htmlThe nonchalance, to me, indicates a nice trust in markets to do their job of optimizing allocation over time. But - if Bitcoin ever starts to become a serious global economic force, mainstream economists are going to flip out over the above quote, given the initial-distribution algo didn't go through some deep analysis, etc... I think it's interesting how the engineering decision of making a simple/transparent (easy to implement, thus more secure) distribution algorithm trumped any potential detailed economic complexity, presumably due to Satoshi's understanding that the market would eventually allocate the capital optimally anyways, given the transparency of the current and future supply. One of the nice things about having a 'benevolent dictator' is that it will be much easier to make decisions about these things going forward. We already know that in the noble interest of getting a 'critical mass' in order to 'outrun regulation', it is critical to subsidize transaction costs. We also know with some reasonable certainty that one of the early attractions of Bitcoin was that people could 'make free money' with only a token effort. People like free shit. Always will. In order to spread the wealth there are two choices. - make more wealth and give it away (e.g., screw the obsolete 21 million cap thingy.) - appropriate existing or lost money and hand it out. Idea! We can be pretty sure that if/when XT takes over, coin tainting is not far behind. Why don't we use the otherwise wasted value to pass around to the masses. Maybe like a dividend to be distributed to all existing addresses. To be more fair and reduce gaming, however, it makes sense that people would need to appropriately register their true identities in order to receive the dividend though. My god, cheezes christ, what a socialist pile of crap. I can personally guarantee that bitcoin with the crucial coin limit will continue, even if I have to run my own miner and wait decennia before the difficulty adjusts. More likely though, I will be joined by at least a percentage of current miners, meaning the system will continue with the slight annoyance of having confirmation times of a day or so. Have your fork, the inflatacoin will go the way of the fiats.
|
|
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 08:23:36 AM |
|
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
Zarathustra
Legendary

Activity: 1162
Merit: 1004
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 08:30:31 AM |
|
I like Satoshi's quote on this: ... Coins have to get initially distributed somehow, and a constant rate seems like the best formula. ...
http://www.mail-archive.com/cryptography%40metzdowd.com/msg09979.htmlThe nonchalance, to me, indicates a nice trust in markets to do their job of optimizing allocation over time. But - if Bitcoin ever starts to become a serious global economic force, mainstream economists are going to flip out over the above quote, given the initial-distribution algo didn't go through some deep analysis, etc... I think it's interesting how the engineering decision of making a simple/transparent (easy to implement, thus more secure) distribution algorithm trumped any potential detailed economic complexity, presumably due to Satoshi's understanding that the market would eventually allocate the capital optimally anyways, given the transparency of the current and future supply. One of the nice things about having a 'benevolent dictator' is that it will be much easier to make decisions about these things going forward. We already know that in the noble interest of getting a 'critical mass' in order to 'outrun regulation', it is critical to subsidize transaction costs. We also know with some reasonable certainty that one of the early attractions of Bitcoin was that people could 'make free money' with only a token effort. People like free shit. Always will. In order to spread the wealth there are two choices. - make more wealth and give it away (e.g., screw the obsolete 21 million cap thingy.) - appropriate existing or lost money and hand it out. Idea! We can be pretty sure that if/when XT takes over, coin tainting is not far behind. Why don't we use the otherwise wasted value to pass around to the masses. Maybe like a dividend to be distributed to all existing addresses. To be more fair and reduce gaming, however, it makes sense that people would need to appropriately register their true identities in order to receive the dividend though. My god, cheezes christ, what a socialist pile of crap. These socialists should be forced to spread their wealth. 'Maybe like a dividend to be distributed to all existing addresses'.
|
|
|
|
|
tvbcof
Legendary

Activity: 5390
Merit: 1370
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 08:49:21 AM |
|
One of the nice things about having a 'benevolent dictator' is that it will be much easier to make decisions about these things going forward. ...
My god, cheezes christ, what a socialist pile of crap. These socialists should be forced to spread their wealth. 'Maybe like a dividend to be distributed to all existing addresses'.Zikes! You guys make some pretty strong arguments and have convinced me of the error of my ways. Let it be known that I hereby drop my support (however brief) for switching Bitcoin to be under a 'benevolent dictator' and under XT. Thanks for setting me right guys.
|
sig spam anywhere and self-moderated threads on the pol&soc board are for losers.
|
|
|
Carlton Banks
Legendary

Activity: 3430
Merit: 3104
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 09:04:33 AM |
|
One of the nice things about having a 'benevolent dictator' is that it will be much easier to make decisions about these things going forward. ...
My god, cheezes christ, what a socialist pile of crap. These socialists should be forced to spread their wealth. 'Maybe like a dividend to be distributed to all existing addresses'.Zikes! You guys make some pretty strong arguments and have convinced me of the error of my ways. Let it be known that I hereby drop my support (however brief) for switching Bitcoin to be under a 'benevolent dictator' and under XT. Thanks for setting me right guys. You're saying Mike Hearn was performing an altruistic power grab? That's not so terrible is it? Who wouldn't want one person to control the way their monetary system develops, the sort of person you can rely on to ignore everything that anyone else has to say and override it with a unilateral hard fork, all because that person knows better? What's wrong with Mike, with his superior understanding of what I want for myself, making more of my decisions for me? Why not all of them? He's a smart guy, and there's no way he'd make decisions on my behalf that benefit him.
|
Vires in numeris
|
|
|
Erdogan
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1005
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 09:18:53 AM |
|
One of the nice things about having a 'benevolent dictator' is that it will be much easier to make decisions about these things going forward. ...
My god, cheezes christ, what a socialist pile of crap. These socialists should be forced to spread their wealth. 'Maybe like a dividend to be distributed to all existing addresses'.Zikes! You guys make some pretty strong arguments and have convinced me of the error of my ways. Let it be known that I hereby drop my support (however brief) for switching Bitcoin to be under a 'benevolent dictator' and under XT. Thanks for setting me right guys. You're saying Mike Hearn was performing an altruistic power grab? That's not so terrible is it? Who wouldn't want one person to control the way their monetary system develops, the sort of person you can rely on to ignore everything that anyone else has to say and override it with a unilateral hard fork, all because that person knows better? What's wrong with Mike, with his superior understanding of what I want for myself, making more of my decisions for me? Why not all of them? He's a smart guy, and there's no way he'd make decisions on my behalf that benefit him. You are being sarcastic, ok, just want to point out that what we have is not a dictator that is an algoritm or a protocol, what we have is free market private money.
|
|
|
|
|
Wexlike
Legendary

Activity: 1474
Merit: 1087
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 12:30:36 PM |
|
Can someone explain to me, why the chinese miners are against a 20mb block size increase? As far as i understand it, no one can force them to mine maxed out blocks. They can limit their own blocks just to 8 mb - or 1 mb in case of a really slow connection.
|
|
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 12:40:36 PM |
|
Can someone explain to me, why the chinese miners are against a 20mb block size increase? As far as i understand it, no one can force them to mine maxed out blocks. They can limit their own blocks just to 8 mb - or 1 mb in case of a really slow connection.
sure they can limit their own block, but nonetheless they need to build blocks on top of other miners blocks, hence they need to download (*) and validate blocks as big as 20MB (potentially). (*) IBLT, matt corallo relay network and the fact that downstream bandwidth costs less than upload could help but maybe not enough for their taste.
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
thezerg
Legendary

Activity: 1246
Merit: 1018
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 12:51:53 PM |
|
One of the nice things about having a 'benevolent dictator' is that it will be much easier to make decisions about these things going forward. ...
My god, cheezes christ, what a socialist pile of crap. These socialists should be forced to spread their wealth. 'Maybe like a dividend to be distributed to all existing addresses'.Zikes! You guys make some pretty strong arguments and have convinced me of the error of my ways. Let it be known that I hereby drop my support (however brief) for switching Bitcoin to be under a 'benevolent dictator' and under XT. Thanks for setting me right guys. You're saying Mike Hearn was performing an altruistic power grab? That's not so terrible is it? Who wouldn't want one person to control the way their monetary system develops, the sort of person you can rely on to ignore everything that anyone else has to say and override it with a unilateral hard fork, all because that person knows better? What's wrong with Mike, with his superior understanding of what I want for myself, making more of my decisions for me? Why not all of them? He's a smart guy, and there's no way he'd make decisions on my behalf that benefit him. These arguments have devolved into stupidity. We'll (the majority) just fork mike out of power if he does something stupid. And implying a 21m increase because of an unrelated txn supply increase is a 5yo's logical fallacy. You guys all need someone/some group in charge so badly that you run home to mamma even when the polled majority clearly wants an increase. But dispute mediation is even more fundamental to how bitcoin works than these other items. Its called open source. Run the rule set you want. My home system WILL easily keep up with 8MB and I support BTC user scalability (I want users in the Philippines to pay in coins) so that's what I'm going to run. Who cares if they (ppl in 2nd or 3rd world or economicly stressed) can't run their own personal copy... especially because 10ppl could pool their resources and do so If you want BTC to be a tool for bankers go ahead and stay on 1MB. In that case the only ppl running a full node will be bankers because they are the only ones who can use the network.
|
|
|
|
|
boumalo
Legendary

Activity: 2058
Merit: 1041
|
 |
June 23, 2015, 01:17:37 PM |
|
Quite a lot of resistance under 1200$ an once for gold.
|
|
|
|
|