cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 03:39:41 PM |
|
|
|
|
|
|
tvbcof
Legendary

Activity: 5390
Merit: 1370
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 03:41:31 PM |
|
There is no such thing as a store of value.
There is no such thing as a thing. Separateness is an illusion. All that exists is the Unified Field and the Void (sort of). Oh sorry, I thought I was in a late night dorm room session discussing our Epistomology 101 homework, not a thread for adults focused on the practical implications of Gold vs Bitcoin. Yo dawg, pass that sick glass you got at Pipes Plus over here...  Here's a store of value. Wow. That's like totally intense, man!
|
sig spam anywhere and self-moderated threads on the pol&soc board are for losers.
|
|
|
awemany
Newbie

Activity: 28
Merit: 0
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 03:53:42 PM |
|
… At this point I'd say just find a way to put the forks on the market and let's arbitrage it out. I will submit if a fork cannot gain the market cap advantage, and I suspect the small-blockers will likewise if Core loses it. Money talks.
I had a strange idea recently: what if we don't even bother with BIP100, BIP101, etc., or trying to come to "consensus" in some formal way. What if, instead, we just make it very easy for node operators to adjust their block size limit. Imagine a drop down menu where you can select "1 MB, 2 MB, 4 MB, 8 MB, … ." What would happen? Personally, I'd just select some big block size limit, like 32 MB. This way, I'd be guaranteed to follow the longest proof of work chain, regardless of what the effective block size limit becomes. I'd expect many people to do the same thing. Eventually, it becomes obvious that the economic majority is supporting a larger limit, and a brave miner publishes a block that is 1.1 MB is size. We all witness that indeed that block got included into the longest proof of work chain, and then suddenly all miners are confident producing 1.1 MB blocks. Thus, the effective block size limit slowly creeps upwards, as this process is repeated over and over as demand for block space grows. TL/DR: maybe we don't need a strict definition for the max block size limit. YES! See also here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3eaxyk/idea_on_bitcoin_mailing_list_blocksize_freely/Instead of a pull down menu, I would favor a free form text field without any default. (For policy neutrality) Pushes the responsibility and the power to set this limit back to the user - where it belongs.
|
|
|
|
|
Peter R
Legendary

Activity: 1162
Merit: 1034
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 03:56:30 PM |
|
… At this point I'd say just find a way to put the forks on the market and let's arbitrage it out. I will submit if a fork cannot gain the market cap advantage, and I suspect the small-blockers will likewise if Core loses it. Money talks.
I had a strange idea recently: what if we don't even bother with BIP100, BIP101, etc., or trying to come to "consensus" in some formal way. What if, instead, we just make it very easy for node operators to adjust their block size limit. Imagine a drop down menu where you can select "1 MB, 2 MB, 4 MB, 8 MB, … ." What would happen? Personally, I'd just select some big block size limit, like 32 MB. This way, I'd be guaranteed to follow the longest proof of work chain, regardless of what the effective block size limit becomes. I'd expect many people to do the same thing. Eventually, it becomes obvious that the economic majority is supporting a larger limit, and a brave miner publishes a block that is 1.1 MB is size. We all witness that indeed that block got included into the longest proof of work chain, and then suddenly all miners are confident producing 1.1 MB blocks. Thus, the effective block size limit slowly creeps upwards, as this process is repeated over and over as demand for block space grows. TL/DR: maybe we don't need a strict definition for the max block size limit. that's just a re-write of what i've been advocating; lift the limit entirely. but yeah, your idea is great b/c it would give full node operators a sense of being in charge via a pull down menu. i like it. don't forget that mining pools are just huge hashing overlays of full nodes which they operate and could use to do the same type of voting. Yes, you have been essentially advocating the same thing. We could take this idea further: in addition to the drop-down menu where node operators and miners select the max block size they'll accept, we could add two new features to improve communication of their decisions: 1. The max block size selected by a node would be written into the header of any blocks the node mines. 2. The P2P protocol would be extended so that nodes could poll other nodes to find out their block size limit. This would be a highly decentralized way of coming to consensus in a very flexible and dynamic manner. It would be a recognition that the block size limit is not part of the consensus layer, but rather part of the transport layer, as sickpig suggested: you know what I can't stop thinking that the max block size is a transport layer constraint that have crept in consensus layer.
The network would dynamically determine the max block size as the network evolves by expressing the size of the blocks they will accept with the drop-down menu on their client. So…is this a good idea? If there are no obvious "gotchas" then perhaps we should write up a BIP.
|
|
|
|
Zangelbert Bingledack
Legendary

Activity: 1036
Merit: 1000
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 03:58:26 PM |
|
This is a fundamental disagreement on the value of Bitcoin then which IMO is first SOV then payment network. There is no such thing as a store of value. You've described the religious approach to understanding money. I'd say the term "store of value" has meaning in the context our current world of fiat money, where you need a hedge against inflation. In the case of Bitcoin while it is still not yet mainstream I think a special definition is useful: an asset that retains or grows its purchasing power over the years (particularly in contrast with fiat money), with growth of course being considered even better as a store of value than simply staying level. Also the difficulty in confiscating it should be part of its store-of-value merits. In world where we were already using gold universally, for example, the concept of "store of value" would probably be unnecessary. However, reading between the lines, I assume your larger point here is that these "store of value" properties rely on Bitcoin being a payment network, too, so there is no clean line where we can say, "For now Bitcoin is only an SoV, so the number of transactions people could use it for doesn't matter." Since the SoV (especially the growth aspect) in the present day owes largely to the investment premise that Bitcoin *will become* a major payment network for the world in the future, the transaction capacity going forward is a key determiner of current price upside and therefore a pivotal element of its SoV properties.
|
|
|
|
|
Peter R
Legendary

Activity: 1162
Merit: 1034
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 04:00:27 PM |
|
Thanks for the link! Sounds like this is already a thing! We should bring more attention to this idea and iron out the details.
|
|
|
|
awemany
Newbie

Activity: 28
Merit: 0
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 04:03:51 PM |
|
[...] So…is this a good idea? If there are no obvious "gotchas" then perhaps we should write up a BIP.
I'd be willing to help! But I'd also suggest to just make it about the configurable setting and leave the rest to the user. I think signalling about blocksize has to happen out-of-band for the time being. Because it is potentially a lot of code complexity. And simple IMO beats complex here. Just make it mandatory to start bitcoind with -maxblocksizelimit (or similar) and have an edit box for bitcoin-qt that has to be filled with a value. The amount of code change should be about the same as BIP101. Start requesting this value at some switchover date in the future - maybe at the beginning of Gavin's increase schedule. Reason for this: Time for user education on building a function Bitcoin network. What do you think?
|
|
|
|
|
Zangelbert Bingledack
Legendary

Activity: 1036
Merit: 1000
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 04:04:25 PM |
|
It would be a recognition that the block size limit is not part of the consensus layer, but rather part of the transport layer, as sickpig suggested: you know what I can't stop thinking that the max block size is a transport layer constraint that have crept in consensus layer.
The network would dynamically determine the max block size as the network evolves by expressing the size of the blocks they will accept with the drop-down menu on their client. This seems too easy, like why wouldn't this have been thought of before. Is the idea that maybe this is one of those cases where muddled thinking (the consensus/transport layer confusion) has prevented people from seeing the obvious? I ask because I'm not sure I understand the full implications of sickpig's comment. EDIT: I think I may get it now: https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3eaxyk/idea_on_bitcoin_mailing_list_blocksize_freely/ctddl6halong with why it hasn't been tried: https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3eaxyk/idea_on_bitcoin_mailing_list_blocksize_freely/ctd812o
|
|
|
|
|
|
kehtolo
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 04:08:00 PM |
|
… At this point I'd say just find a way to put the forks on the market and let's arbitrage it out. I will submit if a fork cannot gain the market cap advantage, and I suspect the small-blockers will likewise if Core loses it. Money talks.
I had a strange idea recently: what if we don't even bother with BIP100, BIP101, etc., or trying to come to "consensus" in some formal way. What if, instead, we just make it very easy for node operators to adjust their block size limit. Imagine a drop down menu where you can select "1 MB, 2 MB, 4 MB, 8 MB, … ." What would happen? Personally, I'd just select some big block size limit, like 32 MB. This way, I'd be guaranteed to follow the longest proof of work chain, regardless of what the effective block size limit becomes. I'd expect many people to do the same thing. Eventually, it becomes obvious that the economic majority is supporting a larger limit, and a brave miner publishes a block that is 1.1 MB is size. We all witness that indeed that block got included into the longest proof of work chain, and then suddenly all miners are confident producing 1.1 MB blocks. Thus, the effective block size limit slowly creeps upwards, as this process is repeated over and over as demand for block space grows. TL/DR: maybe we don't need a strict definition for the max block size limit. that's just a re-write of what i've been advocating; lift the limit entirely. but yeah, your idea is great b/c it would give full node operators a sense of being in charge via a pull down menu. i like it. don't forget that mining pools are just huge hashing overlays of full nodes which they operate and could use to do the same type of voting. Yes, you have been essentially advocating the same thing. We could take this idea further: in addition to the drop-down menu where node operators and miners select the max block size they'll accept, we could add two new features to improve communication of their decisions: 1. The max block size selected by a node would be written into the header of any blocks the node mines. 2. The P2P protocol would be extended so that nodes could poll other nodes to find out their block size limit. This would be a highly decentralized way of coming to consensus in a very flexible and dynamic manner. It would be a recognition that the block size limit is not part of the consensus layer, but rather part of the transport layer, as sickpig suggested: you know what I can't stop thinking that the max block size is a transport layer constraint that have crept in consensus layer.
The network would dynamically determine the max block size as the network evolves by expressing the size of the blocks they will accept with the drop-down menu on their client. So…is this a good idea? If there are no obvious "gotchas" then perhaps we should write up a BIP. It's a wonderful idea! It scales dynamically by reaching a consensus in a decentralised way. The network decides and evolves organically almost. I love it.
|
The next 24 hours are critical!
|
|
|
justusranvier
Legendary

Activity: 1400
Merit: 1069
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 04:17:35 PM |
|
I'd say the term "store of value" has meaning in the context our current world of fiat money, where you need a hedge against inflation. In the case of Bitcoin while it is still not yet mainstream I think a special definition is useful: an asset that retains or grows its purchasing power over the years (particularly in contrast with fiat money), with growth of course being considered even better as a store of value than simply staying level. Also the difficulty in confiscating it should be part of its store-of-value merits. There is certainly a difference between forms of money that work well, and forms of money that don't, that many people have observed throughout history. The problem is that the explanations for those observations are not correct, because they are tautological. They show up in conversations with goldbugs all the time. Q: What is a store of value? A: Anything that has the properties of gold. Q: Why is gold a store of value? A: Because it has intrinsic value. Q: What is value? A: It's what anything with the properties of gold has. Q: Can you give reason why I should buy your gold other than that you want to sell it? A: ...no.
|
|
|
|
|
Peter R
Legendary

Activity: 1162
Merit: 1034
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 04:20:31 PM Last edit: August 13, 2015, 04:34:28 PM by Peter R |
|
[...] So…is this a good idea? If there are no obvious "gotchas" then perhaps we should write up a BIP.
I'd be willing to help! But I'd also suggest to just make it about the configurable setting and leave the rest to the user. I think signalling about blocksize has to happen out-of-band for the time being. Because it is potentially a lot of code complexity. And simple IMO beats complex here. Just make it mandatory to start bitcoind with -maxblocksizelimit (or similar) and have an edit box for bitcoin-qt that has to be filled with a value. The amount of code change should be about the same as BIP101. Start requesting this value at some switchover date in the future - maybe at the beginning of Gavin's increase schedule. Reason for this: Time for user education on building a function Bitcoin network. What do you think? I think that all makes perfect sense, and I agree that simple is better! Perhaps the BIP could only advocate for doing what you said to start, and then there could be a follow-up BIP to do the signalling in the block headers and to add the p2p "block size limit request" messages. The nice thing is that the signalling stuff in the follow-up BIP would have nothing to do with the consensus layer, so it would be much easier to build support for it. I'd be willing to contribute to this too. Realistically, I couldn't do any serious work on this until mid-September, however. Timing wise, it would be great to have a polished proposal published for the second Scalability Workshop in Hong Kong probably in November or December: https://scalingbitcoin.org/I'm actually quite excited about this idea. It has a sort of inevitable feel to it.
|
|
|
|
Erdogan
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1005
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 04:22:57 PM |
|
… At this point I'd say just find a way to put the forks on the market and let's arbitrage it out. I will submit if a fork cannot gain the market cap advantage, and I suspect the small-blockers will likewise if Core loses it. Money talks.
I had a strange idea recently: what if we don't even bother with BIP100, BIP101, etc., or trying to come to "consensus" in some formal way. What if, instead, we just make it very easy for node operators to adjust their block size limit. Imagine a drop down menu where you can select "1 MB, 2 MB, 4 MB, 8 MB, … ." What would happen? Personally, I'd just select some big block size limit, like 32 MB. This way, I'd be guaranteed to follow the longest proof of work chain, regardless of what the effective block size limit becomes. I'd expect many people to do the same thing. Eventually, it becomes obvious that the economic majority is supporting a larger limit, and a brave miner publishes a block that is 1.1 MB is size. We all witness that indeed that block got included into the longest proof of work chain, and then suddenly all miners are confident producing 1.1 MB blocks. Thus, the effective block size limit slowly creeps upwards, as this process is repeated over and over as demand for block space grows. TL/DR: maybe we don't need a strict definition for the max block size limit. That is exactly what I think. The miners will have to try it out or get some feel of what they can do through other channels (social media, conferences, node versions), including associate with other miners. As long as the association is voluntary, it will not form a monopoly.
|
|
|
|
|
Erdogan
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1005
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 04:43:39 PM |
|
Note that this toe dipping is the reality also if we go to 2 MB. There could be some bug related to the network or whatever, that could slip through testing in all environments except the production blockchain. Heck, it is there now, unless we have had a block of excactly 1000000 bytes decimal. I guess some miners are not 100 percent certain that there is not an off-by-one bug there, so they just remove one transaction to be sure.
|
|
|
|
|
iCEBREAKER
Legendary

Activity: 2156
Merit: 1073
Crypto is the separation of Power and State.
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 04:55:53 PM |
|
i really see no technical reasons why we can't have bigger blocks. now.
Then you're not looking hard enough. Here, I'll help: "I think this is a good idea" doesn't count.Stamping your feet and demanding things be done "now" isn't going to help XT. "Not tonight dear" 
|
██████████ ██████████████████ ██████████████████████ ██████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████ ██████████████ ██████████████ ████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████ ██████████████████████ ██████████████████ ██████████ Monero
|
| "The difference between bad and well-developed digital cash will determine whether we have a dictatorship or a real democracy." David Chaum 1996 "Fungibility provides privacy as a side effect." Adam Back 2014
|
| | |
|
|
|
tvbcof
Legendary

Activity: 5390
Merit: 1370
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 04:57:49 PM |
|
The problem is that the explanations for those observations are not correct, because they are tautological. They show up in conversations with goldbugs all the time.
Where do you live? Strawman City? Q: What is a store of value? A: Anything that has the properties of gold. ...
Actually, Bitcoin is something I consider a 'store of value' for a close reason. Neither Bitcoin nor gold have counter-party risk, and that is actually fairly unusual characteristic these days and one I value highly because I consider one of most acute risks associated with wealth preservation to be an economic crisis where one can kiss almost anything with counter-party (or theft) risk bye-bye. What gold has over Bitcoin is that it does not require a free and high capacity internet to function. The only 'bandwidth' that gold needs is a ticker signal and that could be accomplished even with fairly low latency without a functional internet at all. Even then, this need is a nicety more than a necessity. Under conditions of economic crisis I believe it almost certain that there will be a significant clamp-down on the free flow of information. Unfortunately this is termed an 'internet kill switch' which is misleading. I expect it to be implemented as a shift from simply monitoring internet traffic to actively blocking that of it which is potentially damaging to those seeking to maintain control and shape society. IOW, we will still have access to our porn and mainstream movies from an authorized intellectual property owner through large corporate providers, but it will be to 'dangerous to society' for unauthorized people to communicate directly with one another or to allow subversive ideas and data to be disseminated. Bitcoin used in certain sophisticated ways which force multiply the bandwidth still has 'store of value' potential to me which is why I am still a hodler. The simple reason for this is that it can at least in theory function in a world which is much different than we see today but is very likely to exist at the time when it actually matters. That, in a nutshell, is why I am so opposed to growing Bitcoin in simplistic ways which box us in to a reliance on assumptions about the global internet based on the common experiences of today and most people's expectations for tomorrow. 'Dumb growth' hacks off what many people consider to be a vestigial appendage but to me it represents a very big part of the 'store of value' proposition for Bitcoin and one that makes it somewhat competitive with gold.
|
sig spam anywhere and self-moderated threads on the pol&soc board are for losers.
|
|
|
notme
Legendary

Activity: 1904
Merit: 1002
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 05:02:43 PM Last edit: August 13, 2015, 06:16:54 PM by notme |
|
[...] So…is this a good idea? If there are no obvious "gotchas" then perhaps we should write up a BIP.
I'd be willing to help! But I'd also suggest to just make it about the configurable setting and leave the rest to the user. I think signalling about blocksize has to happen out-of-band for the time being. Because it is potentially a lot of code complexity. And simple IMO beats complex here. Just make it mandatory to start bitcoind with -maxblocksizelimit (or similar) and have an edit box for bitcoin-qt that has to be filled with a value. The amount of code change should be about the same as BIP101. Start requesting this value at some switchover date in the future - maybe at the beginning of Gavin's increase schedule. Reason for this: Time for user education on building a function Bitcoin network. What do you think? I think that all makes perfect sense, and I agree that simple is better! Perhaps the BIP could only advocate for doing what you said to start, and then there could be a follow-up BIP to do the signalling in the block headers and to add the p2p "block size limit request" messages. The nice thing is that the signalling stuff in the follow-up BIP would have nothing to do with the consensus layer, so it would be much easier to build support for it. I'd be willing to contribute to this too. Realistically, I couldn't do any serious work on this until mid-September, however. Timing wise, it would be great to have a polished proposal published for the second Scalability Workshop in Hong Kong probably in November or December: https://scalingbitcoin.org/I'm actually quite excited about this idea. It has a sort of inevitable feel to it. What about lying? If enough miners claim to support larger blocks but actually don't, then part of the network will waste time producing blocks that won't be built on. IMO, if we want to put the power directly in miners hands it would be better to raise the limit entirely. However, to do so we would need to test the crap out of everything to be reasonably sure that there aren't bugs that are only uncovered by larger blocks like what happened when the soft limit was raised to 1MB.
|
|
|
|
|
Chainsaw
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 05:04:17 PM |
|
I'm actually quite excited about this idea. It has a sort of inevitable feel to it.
Yes. I've been watching for months. This feels more right than any proposals I've seen to date.
|
|
|
|
Odalv
Legendary

Activity: 1414
Merit: 1000
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 05:54:34 PM |
|
[...] So…is this a good idea? If there are no obvious "gotchas" then perhaps we should write up a BIP.
I'd be willing to help! But I'd also suggest to just make it about the configurable setting and leave the rest to the user. I think signalling about blocksize has to happen out-of-band for the time being. Because it is potentially a lot of code complexity. And simple IMO beats complex here. Just make it mandatory to start bitcoind with -maxblocksizelimit (or similar) and have an edit box for bitcoin-qt that has to be filled with a value. The amount of code change should be about the same as BIP101. Start requesting this value at some switchover date in the future - maybe at the beginning of Gavin's increase schedule. Reason for this: Time for user education on building a function Bitcoin network. What do you think? I think that all makes perfect sense, and I agree that simple is better! Perhaps the BIP could only advocate for doing what you said to start, and then there could be a follow-up BIP to do the signalling in the block headers and to add the p2p "block size limit request" messages. The nice thing is that the signalling stuff in the follow-up BIP would have nothing to do with the consensus layer, so it would be much easier to build support for it. I'd be willing to contribute to this too. Realistically, I couldn't do any serious work on this until mid-September, however. Timing wise, it would be great to have a polished proposal published for the second Scalability Workshop in Hong Kong probably in November or December: https://scalingbitcoin.org/I'm actually quite excited about this idea. It has a sort of inevitable feel to it. What about lying? If enough miners claims to support larger blocks but actually don't, then part of the network will waste time producing blocks that won't be built on. IMO, if we want to put the power directly in miners hands it would be better to raise the limit entirely. However, to do so we would need to test the crap out of everything to be reasonably sure that there aren't bugs that are only uncovered by larger blocks like what happened when the soft limit was raised to 1MB. +1 - I can't wait how this bloat chains supporters will hit the wall. If it was so easy "just increase numbers and we will have 10 times more faster network ... increase to the infinity" :-) - please start XT tomorrow. I like fun.
|
|
|
|
|
thezerg
Legendary

Activity: 1246
Merit: 1018
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 06:28:23 PM |
|
… At this point I'd say just find a way to put the forks on the market and let's arbitrage it out. I will submit if a fork cannot gain the market cap advantage, and I suspect the small-blockers will likewise if Core loses it. Money talks.
I had a strange idea recently: what if we don't even bother with BIP100, BIP101, etc., or trying to come to "consensus" in some formal way. What if, instead, we just make it very easy for node operators to adjust their block size limit. Imagine a drop down menu where you can select "1 MB, 2 MB, 4 MB, 8 MB, … ." What would happen? Personally, I'd just select some big block size limit, like 32 MB. This way, I'd be guaranteed to follow the longest proof of work chain, regardless of what the effective block size limit becomes. I'd expect many people to do the same thing. Eventually, it becomes obvious that the economic majority is supporting a larger limit, and a brave miner publishes a block that is 1.1 MB is size. We all witness that indeed that block got included into the longest proof of work chain, and then suddenly all miners are confident producing 1.1 MB blocks. Thus, the effective block size limit slowly creeps upwards, as this process is repeated over and over as demand for block space grows. TL/DR: maybe we don't need a strict definition for the max block size limit. That is exactly what I think. The miners will have to try it out or get some feel of what they can do through other channels (social media, conferences, node versions), including associate with other miners. As long as the association is voluntary, it will not form a monopoly. yes, this has been considered and discussed before. The danger is that a large block miner cartel might develop naturally whose blocks put small-bandwidth players at a disadvantage. But as others have mentioned, some people are at an electricity cost disadvantage, some bandwidth, some something else... basically it would just be another metric to take into account as you site your miners. So I would be 100% for this if miners could only work with real txns. But a miner could fill up a huge block with a bunch of "fake" (unrelayed, fee pays to himself) txns to artificially drive up network costs. Its too bad Bitcoin doesn't have the "pay portion of fees to miner pool, receive portion for the next N blocks" feature... that idea closes a lot of miner loopholes. But regardless I'm not sure if this "loophole" really is one; it does require 51% of the network to be as connected as you are and willing to process your monster garbage block. I have a hard time believing that miners would do so since over the long term they need bitcoin to succeed. More likely (as you guys suggest) they'll just configure their nodes to ignore monster blocks unless > N deep in the chain.
|
|
|
|
|
Peter R
Legendary

Activity: 1162
Merit: 1034
|
 |
August 13, 2015, 06:36:52 PM |
|
What about lying? If enough miners claim to support larger blocks but actually don't, then part of the network will waste time producing blocks that won't be built on. IMO, if we want to put the power directly in miners hands it would be better to raise the limit entirely. However, to do so we would need to test the crap out of everything to be reasonably sure that there aren't bugs that are only uncovered by larger blocks like what happened when the soft limit was raised to 1MB.
I don't think it would be a problem. Like Erdogan said, the miners will use the "tip-toe" method of increasing the block size. Worst case, a large block gets orphaned and nobody tries again for a while. But if the larger block doesn't get orphaned, then the network will assume that that size is now supported (thereby setting a new effective upper limit). IMO, if we want to put the power directly in miners hands it would be better to raise the limit entirely.
This doesn't put the power directly in the miners' hands. It keeps the power where it already is: in everybody's hands! It just makes it much easier for people to exercise the power they already possess. However, to do so we would need to test the crap out of everything to be reasonably sure that there aren't bugs that are only uncovered by larger blocks like what happened when the soft limit was raised to 1MB.
I disagree. For example, I would not set my node's limit to anything greater than 32 MB until I understood the 33.5 MB message size limitation better. I expect many people would do the same thing. Rational miners won't dare to randomly publish a 100 MB block, because they'd be worried that it would be orphaned. Furthermore, since miners would likely use the "tip-toe" method, the effective block size limit will grow only in very small increments, helping to reveal any potential limitations before they become problems.
|
|
|
|
|