Users that you should merit

[suchmoon]

Credit for inspiration goes to DdmrDdmr. I'm taking a slightly different approach, i.e. instead of re-meriting users that I have already merited, I'm looking for users that earned a lot of merits but I never merited them. And I'm not trying to break any merit sending records, simply looking for users who might deserve merits.

If you would like to get a list of users based on publicly available criteria (without analyzing the contents of posts) - post a request in the thread and I'll do my best. For example:

1) Users who earned more than N merits but you never merited them. N = 100 is ~700 users, N = 30 is ~2000 users.
2) Users who earned more than N merits since date D.
3) Users who earned more than N merits on high-quality boards X, Y, and Z.
4) Users who earned less than N merits, never posted on spam boards X, Y, and Z, made at least K posts since date D.

etc. The list will be limited to 100 users so please choose a sort order as well.

See a sample list below. Note that the "Ban" column is likely inaccurate since I can't reliably track unbanned users nor signature bans. Make sure to check user profile and BPIP.

Thanks to LoyceV and Vod for their sites.

[1714899323]

1714899323

[BitcoinGirl.Club]

For example:

1) Users who earned more than N merits but you never merited them. N > 100 is ~700 users, N > 30 is ~2000 users.
2) Users who earned more than N merits since date D.
3) Users earned more than N merits on high-quality boards X, Y, and Z.
4) Users earned less than N merits, never posted on spam boards X, Y, and Z, made at least K posts since date D.

1. N = 100 All time
2. N = 100 last 120 days.
3. N = 100, WO, Gambling discussions
4. N = 100 Altcoin discussions.

Not a merit source to actively merit users with huge amount of sMerits but I would love to order some stats here.

Thanks LoyceV suchmoon (Blame goes to Foxpup, I am innocent 🙂)

* Fixed the serial number for you

[suchmoon]

Thanks LoyceV

* Fixed the serial number for you

Thanks. Did you call me LoyceV? I should probably ask Foxpup to give me a motorcycle or something

So what do you wanna see? Pick one of the sample criteria in the OP or you can come up with something else.

[BitcoinGirl.Club]

Thanks LoyceV

* Fixed the serial number for you

Thanks. Did you call me LoyceV?

(LOL yes) it's the Avatar. That's fucking confusing if someone do not read the username above which I did this time 😜

I should probably ask Foxpup to give me a motorcycle or something

Foxpup needs to give you something else to identify you. A lambo?

So what do you wanna see? Pick one of the sample criteria in the OP or you can come up with something else.

Updated my last post. 🙂

[suchmoon]

Ok, one at a time.

1. N = 100 All time

Since the list is limited to 100 users, it's going to be N = 435.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. theymos                      4994   8601  Trust  BPIP      
   2. suchmoon                     2647  16806  Trust  BPIP      
   3. DdmrDdmr                     2426   2761  Trust  BPIP      
   4. o_e_l_e_o                    2224   3775  Trust  BPIP      
   5. The Pharmacist               2005  10928  Trust  BPIP      
   6. satoshi                      1815    575  Trust  BPIP      
   7. hilariousetc                 1648   3187  Trust  BPIP      
   8. achow101                     1517  11148  Trust  BPIP      
   9. gmaxwell                     1333   5037  Trust  BPIP      
  10. Vod                          1269  17650  Trust  BPIP      
  11. abhiseshakana                1253   1189  Trust  BPIP      
  12. 1miau                        1192   1008  Trust  BPIP      
  13. HCP                          1185   6459  Trust  BPIP      
  14. Jet Cash                     1184   6430  Trust  BPIP      
  15. xtraelv                      1174   1980  Trust  BPIP      
  16. krogothmanhattan             1168   6141  Trust  BPIP      
  17. qwk                          1129   6203  Trust  BPIP      
  18. iasenko                      1128   2760  Trust  BPIP      
  19. Piggy                        1110   4629  Trust  BPIP      
  20. Lauda                        1086  25215  Trust  BPIP      
  21. joniboini                    1066   3087  Trust  BPIP      
  22. coinlocket$                  1040   4629  Trust  BPIP      
  23. TMAN                         1037   5360  Trust  BPIP      
  24. mikeywith                     993   2318  Trust  BPIP      
  25. marlboroza                    980   5620  Trust  BPIP      
  26. bob123                        976   3813  Trust  BPIP      
  27. roycilik                      950   1954  Trust  BPIP      
  28. theyoungmillionaire           900    361  Trust  BPIP      
  29. SaltySpitoon                  881   4295  Trust  BPIP      
  30. mu_enrico                     873   1280  Trust  BPIP      
  31. ICOEthics                     863   2214  Trust  BPIP      
  32. Alex_Sr                       861   1450  Trust  BPIP      
  33. ETFbitcoin                    854   2713  Trust  BPIP      
  34. JayJuanGee                    847  16719  Trust  BPIP      
  35. BitCryptex                    844    984  Trust  BPIP      
  36. Husna QA                      820    906  Trust  BPIP      
  37. gentlemand                    807  16893  Trust  BPIP      
  38. jojo69                        793   6678  Trust  BPIP      
  39. Lutpin                        791   5829  Trust  BPIP      
  40. PHI1618                       785   3216  Trust  BPIP      
  41. philipma1957                  783  30484  Trust  BPIP      
  42. Xal0lex                       781   2207  Trust  BPIP      
  43. nullius                       777    928  Trust  BPIP      
  44. Carlton Banks                 774   7505  Trust  BPIP      
  45. infofront                     764   2841  Trust  BPIP      
  46. taikuri13                     754   2176  Trust  BPIP      
  47. pooya87                       752  11020  Trust  BPIP      
  48. morvillz7z                    749    971  Trust  BPIP      
  49. minerjones                    747   9880  Trust  BPIP      
  50. pandukelana2712               745    867  Trust  BPIP      
  51. Coolcryptovator               731   3029  Trust  BPIP      
  52. OgNasty                       698   8481  Trust  BPIP      
  53. yogg                          694   2972  Trust  BPIP      
  54. Veleor                        688   1345  Trust  BPIP      
  55. bones261                      655   5276  Trust  BPIP      
  56. CryptopreneurBrainboss        645   1447  Trust  BPIP      
  57. DireWolfM14                   645   1348  Trust  BPIP      
  58. actmyname                     643   4609  Trust  BPIP      
  59. Goran_                        640   3915  Trust  BPIP      
  60. mole0815                      638   2551  Trust  BPIP      
  61. Flying Hellfish               634   2223  Trust  BPIP      
  62. asche                         634   4279  Trust  BPIP      
  63. mocacinno                     631   3161  Trust  BPIP      
  64. LeGaulois                     627   5210  Trust  BPIP      
  65. hilariousandco                608  20334  Trust  BPIP      
  66. Pmalek                        594   2244  Trust  BPIP      
  67. Lafu                          593   3269  Trust  BPIP      
  68. yahoo62278                    556   6652  Trust  BPIP      
  69. stompix                       547   6639  Trust  BPIP      
  70. wwzsocki                      540   3483  Trust  BPIP      
  71. GameKyuubi                    535    245  Trust  BPIP      
  72. d_eddie                       529   2220  Trust  BPIP      
  73. Foxpup                        527   3551  Trust  BPIP      
  74. Matthias9515                  527   2320  Trust  BPIP      
  75. bill gator                    525   2963  Trust  BPIP      
  76. d5000                         516   5548  Trust  BPIP      
  77. bitserve                      513   4643  Trust  BPIP      
  78. chimk                         512   3224  Trust  BPIP      
  79. sncc                          508    534  Trust  BPIP      
  80. Coin-1                        507   1995  Trust  BPIP      
  81. Smart man                     502   1143  Trust  BPIP      
  82. zazarb                        482   7321  Trust  BPIP      
  83. pitipawn                      478    563  Trust  BPIP      
  84. tvplus006                     475   1803  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  85. BTCforJoe                     473   2587  Trust  BPIP      
  86. mjglqw                        472   6011  Trust  BPIP      
  87. cryptovigi                    472   1194  Trust  BPIP      
  88. lovesmayfamilis               471   1682  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  89. Welsh                         460   4426  Trust  BPIP      
  90. Hal                           457    314  Trust  BPIP      
  91. hugeblack                     457   2964  Trust  BPIP      
  92. cabalism13                    454   1661  Trust  BPIP      
  93. sidehack                      453   6349  Trust  BPIP      
  94. nullCoiner                    451   3783  Trust  BPIP      
  95. AdolfinWolf                   450   3058  Trust  BPIP      
  96. TheQuin                       449   5408  Trust  BPIP      
  97. eddie13                       449   1951  Trust  BPIP      
  98. TheFuzzStone                  449   2101  Trust  BPIP      
  99. xenon131                      436    895  Trust  BPIP      
 100. Elwar                         435  10466  Trust  BPIP      

[suchmoon]

2. N = 100 last 120 days.

Again limited to 100 users so it's effectively N = 154. Excluding users whom you merited at any time (not just within last 120 days).

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. theymos                       938   8601  Trust  BPIP      
   2. suchmoon                      909  16806  Trust  BPIP      
   3. o_e_l_e_o                     804   3775  Trust  BPIP      
   4. 1miau                         614   1008  Trust  BPIP      
   5. DdmrDdmr                      507   2761  Trust  BPIP      
   6. abhiseshakana                 475   1189  Trust  BPIP      
   7. mikeywith                     447   2318  Trust  BPIP      
   8. The Pharmacist                446  10928  Trust  BPIP      
   9. HCP                           442   6459  Trust  BPIP      
  10. Xal0lex                       402   2207  Trust  BPIP      
  11. bob123                        395   3813  Trust  BPIP      
  12. yogg                          386   2972  Trust  BPIP      
  13. CryptopreneurBrainboss        384   1447  Trust  BPIP      
  14. wwzsocki                      383   3483  Trust  BPIP      
  15. achow101                      373  11148  Trust  BPIP      
  16. ICOEthics                     366   2214  Trust  BPIP      
  17. DireWolfM14                   359   1348  Trust  BPIP      
  18. morvillz7z                    352    971  Trust  BPIP      
  19. roycilik                      339   1954  Trust  BPIP      
  20. SaltySpitoon                  319   4295  Trust  BPIP      
  21. Husna QA                      302    906  Trust  BPIP      
  22. iasenko                       298   2760  Trust  BPIP      
  23. krogothmanhattan              295   6141  Trust  BPIP      
  24. marlboroza                    289   5620  Trust  BPIP      
  25. pooya87                       288  11020  Trust  BPIP      
  26. Veleor                        286   1345  Trust  BPIP      
  27. GreatArkansas                 285   1309  Trust  BPIP      
  28. taikuri13                     282   2176  Trust  BPIP      
  29. qwk                           276   6203  Trust  BPIP      
  30. mu_enrico                     275   1280  Trust  BPIP      
  31. cabalism13                    270   1661  Trust  BPIP      
  32. asu                           269    981  Trust  BPIP      
  33. PHI1618                       269   3216  Trust  BPIP      
  34. Tytanowy Janusz               268   1164  Trust  BPIP      
  35. theyoungmillionaire           265    361  Trust  BPIP      
  36. coinlocket$                   262   4629  Trust  BPIP      
  37. pandukelana2712               255    867  Trust  BPIP      
  38. bones261                      252   5276  Trust  BPIP      
  39. ryzaadit                      248   1526  Trust  BPIP      
  40. hilariousetc                  245   3187  Trust  BPIP      
  41. gmaxwell                      244   5037  Trust  BPIP      
  42. Eliovp                        242   1020  Trust  BPIP      
  43. yazher                        240    717  Trust  BPIP      
  44. chimk                         240   3224  Trust  BPIP      
  45. Matthias9515                  239   2320  Trust  BPIP      
  46. Lauda                         234  25215  Trust  BPIP      
  47. ETFbitcoin                    233   2713  Trust  BPIP      
  48. gentlemand                    227  16893  Trust  BPIP      
  49. BitCryptex                    227    984  Trust  BPIP      
  50. Vod                           224  17650  Trust  BPIP      
  51. FontSeli                      222   1168  Trust  BPIP      
  52. Goran_                        219   3915  Trust  BPIP      
  53. lovesmayfamilis               218   1682  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  54. Carlton Banks                 216   7505  Trust  BPIP      
  55. JayJuanGee                    215  16719  Trust  BPIP      
  56. actmyname                     215   4609  Trust  BPIP      
  57. crwth                         209   5018  Trust  BPIP      
  58. TheFuzzStone                  205   2101  Trust  BPIP      
  59. tk808                         204   2297  Trust  BPIP      
  60. xenon131                      204    895  Trust  BPIP      
  61. minerjones                    199   9880  Trust  BPIP      
  62. philipma1957                  197  30484  Trust  BPIP      
  63. madnessteat                   195   1112  Trust  BPIP      
  64. joniboini                     191   3087  Trust  BPIP      
  65. cryptovigi                    191   1194  Trust  BPIP      
  66. Alex_Sr                       191   1450  Trust  BPIP      
  67. AdolfinWolf                   190   3058  Trust  BPIP      
  68. Foxpup                        189   3551  Trust  BPIP      
  69. EcuaMobi                      182   3789  Trust  BPIP      
  70. kawetsriyanto                 181   1308  Trust  BPIP      
  71. aundroid                      180   1911  Trust  BPIP      
  72. mocacinno                     179   3161  Trust  BPIP      
  73. igor72                        179    831  Trust  BPIP      
  74. Flying Hellfish               178   2223  Trust  BPIP      
  75. Pmalek                        176   2244  Trust  BPIP      
  76. tbct_mt2                      176   1096  Trust  BPIP      
  77. whotookmycrypto               176    168  Trust  BPIP      
  78. Lafu                          175   3269  Trust  BPIP      
  79. TMAN                          172   5360  Trust  BPIP      
  80. anonymousminer                171   1676  Trust  BPIP      
  81. masulum                       168    610  Trust  BPIP      
  82. MrFreeRoMan                   168    774  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  83. TECSHARE                      166   8222  Trust  BPIP      
  84. nc50lc                        163   1453  Trust  BPIP      
  85. asche                         163   4279  Trust  BPIP      
  86. Coolcryptovator               163   3029  Trust  BPIP      
  87. monkeynuts                    162   1213  Trust  BPIP      
  88. gospodin                      162   3503  Trust  BPIP      
  89. Jean_Luc                      161    192  Trust  BPIP      
  90. Vispilio                      160   1472  Trust  BPIP      
  91. hilariousandco                159  20334  Trust  BPIP      
  92. nopara73                      159     42  Trust  BPIP      
  93. Coin-1                        159   1999  Trust  BPIP      
  94. Royse777                      158   2677  Trust  BPIP      
  95. AverageGlabella               155    348  Trust  BPIP      
  96. xtraelv                       155   1980  Trust  BPIP      
  97. ChiBitCTy                     155   1359  Trust  BPIP  Sig 
  98. Sharon121212                  155    366  Trust  BPIP      
  99. infofront                     154   2841  Trust  BPIP      
 100. Baofeng                       154   2866  Trust  BPIP      

[Quickseller]

Ok, one at a time.

1. N = 100 All time

Since the list is limited to 100 users, it's going to be N = 435.

  51. Coolcryptovator               731   3029  Trust  BPIP      
  52. OgNasty                       698   8481  Trust  BPIP      

Your list is inaccurate. I have 712 merit. You claim to listing everyone with merit above 435, but you clearly did not do this.

[suchmoon]

3. N = 100, WO, Gambling discussions

Excluding users whom you merited on any board (not just WO/GD).

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. jojo69                        774   6678  Trust  BPIP      
   2. infofront                     706   2841  Trust  BPIP      
   3. JayJuanGee                    650  16719  Trust  BPIP      
   4. d_eddie                       503   2220  Trust  BPIP      
   5. bitserve                      472   4643  Trust  BPIP      
   6. Elwar                         364  10466  Trust  BPIP      
   7. gentlemand                    362  16893  Trust  BPIP      
   8. Paashaas                      362   1963  Trust  BPIP      
   9. Globb0                        304   2565  Trust  BPIP      
  10. cAPSLOCK                      287   2655  Trust  BPIP      
  11. RejectedBanana                278    384  Trust  BPIP      
  12. JimboToronto                  266   6396  Trust  BPIP      
  13. BTCMILLIONAIRE                247   6149  Trust  BPIP      
  14. goldkingcoiner                247   1211  Trust  BPIP      
  15. Rosewater Foundation          244   2475  Trust  BPIP      
  16. jbreher                       226   6156  Trust  BPIP      
  17. kurious                       224   2830  Trust  BPIP      
  18. Lambie Slayer                 217    848  Trust  BPIP      
  19. TERA2                         194   1669  Trust  BPIP      
  20. realr0ach                     192   3442  Trust  BPIP      
  21. bones261                      182   5276  Trust  BPIP      
  22. Phil_S                        177    839  Trust  BPIP      
  23. Kylapoiss                     169    562  Trust  BPIP      
  24. 600watt                       163   5830  Trust  BPIP      
  25. Icygreen                      158    746  Trust  BPIP      
  26. marcus_of_augustus            156   7340  Trust  BPIP      
  27. kingcolex                     154   9898  Trust  BPIP      
  28. yefi                          152   2214  Trust  BPIP      
  29. Hueristic                     140   8653  Trust  BPIP      
  30. Wekkel                        137   4516  Trust  BPIP      
  31. Arriemoller                   132   1303  Trust  BPIP      
  32. toknormal                     129   6857  Trust  BPIP      
  33. Anon136                       121   6587  Trust  BPIP      
  34. Spaceman_Spiff_Original       119    358  Trust  BPIP      
  35. Cryptotourist                 108   1002  Trust  BPIP      
  36. BinaryReign                   105    141  Trust  BPIP      
  37. kirreev070                    105    736  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  38. vapourminer                   103   2385  Trust  BPIP      
  39. bitcoinPsycho                 103   1188  Trust  BPIP      
  40. stadus                        100   2959  Trust  BPIP      

4. N = 100 Altcoin discussions.

You might want to narrow it down (e.g. by date and/or post count and/or post length) since that's gonna be 2 million users. I would also suggest to exclude Bounties.

Your list is inaccurate. I have 712 merit. You claim to listing everyone with merit above 435, but you clearly did not do this.

1) Users who earned more than N merits but you never merited them. N = 100 is ~700 users, N = 30 is ~2000 users.

Pamoldar has merited you.

[bob123]

Your list is inaccurate. I have 712 merit. You claim to listing everyone with merit above 435, but you clearly did not do this.

You should read the OP again..

[...]
1) Users who earned more than N merits but you never merited them.
[...]

The list you have quoted was the response to the request from Pamoldar.
And he has merited you at least once:

Code:

May 31, 2019, 05:12:00 AM: 1 to Quickseller for Re: Feedback needed on risked amount

In the future, please read the OP properly before trying to bash anyone you don't like..

[Foxpup]

Requesting users never merited by me who earned more than 500 merits outside of Wall Observer, sorted by merits/post, please.

I should probably ask Foxpup to give me a motorcycle or something

Sorry. Gotta fight global warming as well as shitposters.

[suchmoon]

Requesting users never merited by me who earned more than 500 merits outside of Wall Observer, sorted by merits/post, please.

The "Merits" column is the number of merits earned outside of WO, not the total merits. "Posts" is total. Same for Pamoldar's request above. I feel I need to state this before I get sued for "criminal defamation"

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. satoshi                      1815    575  Trust  BPIP      
   2. GameKyuubi                    535    245  Trust  BPIP      
   3. abhiseshakana                1253   1189  Trust  BPIP      
   4. pandukelana2712               745    867  Trust  BPIP      
   5. roycilik                      950   1954  Trust  BPIP      
   6. Smart man                     502   1143  Trust  BPIP      
   7. mikeywith                     981   2318  Trust  BPIP      
   8. fillippone                    528   1306  Trust  BPIP      
   9. Artemis3                      549   1393  Trust  BPIP      
  10. taikuri13                     754   2176  Trust  BPIP      
  11. joniboini                    1066   3087  Trust  BPIP      
  12. mole0815                      638   2551  Trust  BPIP      
  13. PHI1618                       785   3216  Trust  BPIP      
  14. Coolcryptovator               731   3029  Trust  BPIP      
  15. Matthias9515                  527   2320  Trust  BPIP      
  16. HeRetiK                       579   2712  Trust  BPIP      
  17. krogothmanhattan             1169   6141  Trust  BPIP      
  18. Goran_                        640   3915  Trust  BPIP      
  19. wwzsocki                      529   3483  Trust  BPIP      
  20. asche                         633   4279  Trust  BPIP      
  21. LeGaulois                     627   5210  Trust  BPIP      
  22. minerjones                    747   9880  Trust  BPIP      
  23. Quickseller                   712  14302  Trust  BPIP      
  24. micgoossens                   523  10579  Trust  BPIP      
  25. philipma1957                  782  30484  Trust  BPIP      

[fillippone]

Requesting users never merited by me who earned more than 500 merits outside of Wall Observer, sorted by merits/post, please.

The "Merits" column is the number of merits earned outside of WO, not the total merits. "Posts" is total. Same for Pamoldar's request above. I feel I need to state this before I get sued for "criminal defamation"

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. satoshi                      1815    575  Trust  BPIP      
   2. GameKyuubi                    535    245  Trust  BPIP      
   3. abhiseshakana                1253   1189  Trust  BPIP      
   4. pandukelana2712               745    867  Trust  BPIP      
   5. roycilik                      950   1954  Trust  BPIP      
   6. Smart man                     502   1143  Trust  BPIP      
   7. mikeywith                     981   2318  Trust  BPIP      
   8. fillippone                    528   1306  Trust  BPIP      
   9. Artemis3                      549   1393  Trust  BPIP      
  10. taikuri13                     754   2176  Trust  BPIP      
  11. joniboini                    1066   3087  Trust  BPIP      
  12. mole0815                      638   2551  Trust  BPIP      
  13. PHI1618                       785   3216  Trust  BPIP      
  14. Coolcryptovator               731   3029  Trust  BPIP      
  15. Matthias9515                  527   2320  Trust  BPIP      
  16. HeRetiK                       579   2712  Trust  BPIP      
  17. krogothmanhattan             1169   6141  Trust  BPIP      
  18. Goran_                        640   3915  Trust  BPIP      
  19. wwzsocki                      529   3483  Trust  BPIP      
  20. asche                         633   4279  Trust  BPIP      
  21. LeGaulois                     627   5210  Trust  BPIP      
  22. minerjones                    747   9880  Trust  BPIP      
  23. Quickseller                   712  14302  Trust  BPIP      
  24. micgoossens                   523  10579  Trust  BPIP      
  25. philipma1957                  782  30484  Trust  BPIP      

Writing here because notified by majordomo.
What’s wrong with WO? I usually put some good content also in there.
Just asking.
Happy to be reviewed btw.

Edit:
I reckon good post get completely un noticed (as https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=178336.msg51805460#msg51805460) while meme get rains of merits.

[CryptopreneurBrainboss]

@Foxpup and others, using the never merited criteria might deprived some quality individuals of recieving merit from you guys as just for a user to have received only one merit from you guys it results to he/she misses out. Maybe Below 5/10 or any reasonable number would work better.

[LoyceV]

I'm looking for users that earned a lot of merits but I never merited them.

I would expect this list to be topped by users who post in languages I can't read. Or maybe users who post on the mining board.

I'd like to see which all users who earned more than N Merit, but never received any from me. Can you make N high enough to show the 100 top-Merit-earning-users that I missed? It can be earned on all boards. I'm hoping/guessing N is around 200 for this.

I can use this data to beat suchmoon's top position on meriting-most-different-users Only 81 to go:

    1. 16960 Merit sent by suchmoon (#234771) to 1175 unique users in 3928 transactions
     6. 5054 Merit sent by LoyceV (#459836) to 1094 unique users in 3776 transactions

[o_e_l_e_o]

Can you make N high enough to show the 100 top-Merit-earning-users that I missed?

This, but for me please.

[suchmoon]

@Foxpup and others, using the never merited criteria might deprived some quality individuals of recieving merit from you guys as just for a user to have received only one merit from you guys it results to he/she misses out. Maybe Below 5/10 or any reasonable number would work better.

That's a good point. I experimented with that a little bit for my own list but there are still so many unmerited users I want to review that I'm probably a few weeks away from raising this criteria from 0 to ~10 or so.

I'd like to see which all users who earned more than N Merit, but never received any from me. Can you make N high enough to show the 100 top-Merit-earning-users that I missed? It can be earned on all boards. I'm hoping/guessing N is around 200 for this.

N = 223

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. abhiseshakana                1253   1189  Trust  BPIP      
   2. roycilik                      950   1954  Trust  BPIP      
   3. Toxic2040                     922   2111  Trust  BPIP      
   4. Husna QA                      820    906  Trust  BPIP      
   5. jojo69                        793   6678  Trust  BPIP      
   6. pandukelana2712               745    867  Trust  BPIP      
   7. Goran_                        640   3915  Trust  BPIP      
   8. mole0815                      638   2551  Trust  BPIP      
   9. d_eddie                       529   2220  Trust  BPIP      
  10. bitserve                      513   4643  Trust  BPIP      
  11. chimk                         512   3224  Trust  BPIP      
  12. Smart man                     502   1143  Trust  BPIP      
  13. zazarb                        482   7321  Trust  BPIP      
  14. pitipawn                      478    563  Trust  BPIP      
  15. tvplus006                     475   1803  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  16. sidehack                      453   6349  Trust  BPIP      
  17. nullCoiner                    451   3783  Trust  BPIP      
  18. TheFuzzStone                  450   2101  Trust  BPIP      
  19. ryzaadit                      431   1526  Trust  BPIP      
  20. anonymousminer                425   1676  Trust  BPIP      
  21. aundroid                      416   1911  Trust  BPIP      
  22. poptop                        409   5059  Trust  BPIP      
  23. Scheede                       401   2358  Trust  BPIP      
  24. romanornr                     400    678  Trust  BPIP      
  25. igor72                        396    831  Trust  BPIP      
  26. Kryptowerk                    392   2186  Trust  BPIP      
  27. HagssFIN                      382   3287  Trust  BPIP      
  28. explorder                     378    466  Trust  BPIP      
  29. Plutosky                      377    789  Trust  BPIP      
  30. Globb0                        376   2565  Trust  BPIP      
  31. deeperx                       373   1662  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  32. cAPSLOCK                      372   2655  Trust  BPIP      
  33. Paashaas                      366   1963  Trust  BPIP      
  34. sabotag3x                     362   8532  Trust  BPIP      
  35. AlyattesLydia                 335   1805  Trust  BPIP      
  36. gawlea                        329   1234  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  37. bct_ail                       320   3633  Trust  BPIP      
  38. trantute2                     320    708  Trust  BPIP      
  39. kawetsriyanto                 306   1308  Trust  BPIP      
  40. mstfprcn                      303   1871  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  41. finaleshot2016                301   1283  Trust  BPIP      
  42. jbreher                       298   6156  Trust  BPIP      
  43. Claymore                      296   2278  Trust  BPIP      
  44. Nestade                       294   1451  Trust  BPIP      
  45. johhnyUA                      290   3465  Trust  BPIP      
  46. squatz1                       290   2816  Trust  BPIP      
  47. leonello                      290   1064  Trust  BPIP      
  48. GreatArkansas                 289   1309  Trust  BPIP      
  49. gospodin                      286   3503  Trust  BPIP      
  50. duesoldi                      284   2037  Trust  BPIP      
  51. goldkingcoiner                284   1211  Trust  BPIP      
  52. RichDaniel                    283    479  Trust  BPIP      
  53. 600watt                       279   5830  Trust  BPIP      
  54. dbshck                        279   2016  Trust  BPIP      
  55. asu                           279    981  Trust  BPIP      
  56. Trofo                         279   2737  Trust  BPIP      
  57. by rallier                    277   2174  Trust  BPIP      
  58. sheenshane                    273   2170  Trust  BPIP      
  59. JimboToronto                  272   6396  Trust  BPIP      
  60. BTCMILLIONAIRE                271   6149  Trust  BPIP      
  61. BitcoinTurk                   271   3142  Trust  BPIP      
  62. baba0000000000                270   2919  Trust  BPIP      
  63. Juliya_D                      270   1011  Trust  BPIP      
  64. kzv                           267   2679  Trust  BPIP      
  65. Hilde X                       261   2682  Trust  BPIP      
  66. Lakai01                       260   1118  Trust  BPIP      
  67. zonefloor                     259   1159  Trust  BPIP      
  68. kurious                       258   2830  Trust  BPIP      
  69. alex bond                     258    746  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  70. Aerys2                        257   2587  Trust  BPIP      
  71. bobita                        256   2555  Trust  BPIP      
  72. imhoneer                      254   2062  Trust  BPIP      
  73. saulzaents                    251   1002  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  74. RuSS512                       251    702  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  75. identifyuser                  250   1119  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  76. Ajpa94                        250     11  Trust  BPIP      
  77. fine99                        250    857  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  78. Tukang Becak                  250   1012  Trust  BPIP      
  79. ATMcoin                       250   1083  Trust  BPIP      
  80. Paolo.Demidov                 250   1185  Trust  BPIP      
  81. Biodom                        248   6116  Trust  BPIP      
  82. MoxnatyShmel                  247   4992  Trust  BPIP      
  83. Eliovp                        245   1020  Trust  BPIP      
  84. SyGambler                     245   4541  Trust  BPIP      
  85. phantastisch                  244   2220  Trust  BPIP      
  86. TheBobyHunter                 244    569  Trust  BPIP      
  87. Rosewater Foundation          244   2475  Trust  BPIP      
  88. FontSeli                      242   1168  Trust  BPIP      
  89. teramit                       241   1420  Trust  BPIP      
  90. frankbitcoin                  241   1580  Trust  BPIP      
  91. vizique                       236   2331  Trust  BPIP      
  92. ocminer                       233  14964  Trust  BPIP      
  93. GrosWesh                      231   1379  Trust  BPIP      
  94. jillscarbrough                228   1024  Trust  BPIP      
  95. Twinscoin2017                 228    815  Trust  BPIP      
  96. Speculatoross                 228   1000  Trust  BPIP      
  97. jstefanop                     227   1513  Trust  BPIP      
  98. ui_zakharchenko               225   2077  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  99. wh1rlw1nd                     225   1097  Trust  BPIP      
 100. panjay                        223    923  Trust  BPIP      

I can use this data to beat suchmoon's top position on meriting-most-different-users Only 81 to go:

I knew you would

You gonna need to learn a few languages to get 81 out of that list though.

I reckon good post get completely un noticed (as https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=178336.msg51805460#msg51805460) while meme get rains of merits.

That's one of the problems with WO. You're unlikely to get merits there from non-resident wall observers ("outsiders" won't read thousands of pages) and "regulars" tend to merit rockets and mic's dinner etc. Nothing wrong with that, just a different type of environment.

[LoyceV]

I'd like to see which all users who earned more than N Merit, but never received any from me. Can you make N high enough to show the 100 top-Merit-earning-users that I missed? It can be earned on all boards. I'm hoping/guessing N is around 200 for this.

N = 223

Thanks! That means I've merited 191 out of the 291 top-merited-users

I'm surprised by the number of names I recognize.

You gonna need to learn a few languages to get 81 out of that list though.

I quickly checked the first 10, but didn't find anything I would Merit yet.

[suchmoon]

Can you make N high enough to show the 100 top-Merit-earning-users that I missed?

This, but for me please.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. xhomerx10                    1229   5351  Trust  BPIP      
   2. HairyMaclairy                1194   6690  Trust  BPIP      
   3. krogothmanhattan             1169   6141  Trust  BPIP      
   4. roycilik                      950   1954  Trust  BPIP      
   5. Toxic2040                     922   2111  Trust  BPIP      
   6. mu_enrico                     873   1280  Trust  BPIP      
   7. kenzawak                      833   5563  Trust  BPIP      
   8. jojo69                        793   6678  Trust  BPIP      
   9. Lutpin                        791   5829  Trust  BPIP      
  10. PHI1618                       785   3216  Trust  BPIP      
  11. philipma1957                  783  30484  Trust  BPIP      
  12. Xal0lex                       781   2207  Trust  BPIP      
  13. infofront                     764   2841  Trust  BPIP      
  14. pandukelana2712               745    867  Trust  BPIP      
  15. VB1001                        670   1646  Trust  BPIP      
  16. Goran_                        640   3915  Trust  BPIP      
  17. mole0815                      638   2551  Trust  BPIP      
  18. Lafu                          593   3269  Trust  BPIP      
  19. witcher_sense                 550   1149  Trust  BPIP      
  20. GameKyuubi                    535    245  Trust  BPIP      
  21. d_eddie                       529   2220  Trust  BPIP      
  22. Matthias9515                  527   2320  Trust  BPIP      
  23. bitserve                      513   4643  Trust  BPIP      
  24. chimk                         512   3224  Trust  BPIP      
  25. sncc                          508    534  Trust  BPIP      
  26. Coin-1                        507   1999  Trust  BPIP      
  27. Smart man                     502   1143  Trust  BPIP      
  28. Torque                        501   5133  Trust  BPIP      
  29. BitcoinPenny                  493   2021  Trust  BPIP      
  30. zazarb                        482   7321  Trust  BPIP      
  31. pitipawn                      478    563  Trust  BPIP      
  32. BTCforJoe                     473   2587  Trust  BPIP      
  33. Hal                           457    314  Trust  BPIP      
  34. hugeblack                     457   2964  Trust  BPIP      
  35. sidehack                      453   6349  Trust  BPIP      
  36. nullCoiner                    451   3783  Trust  BPIP      
  37. TheFuzzStone                  450   2101  Trust  BPIP      
  38. ryzaadit                      431   1526  Trust  BPIP      
  39. anonymousminer                425   1676  Trust  BPIP      
  40. esmanthra                     418   1524  Trust  BPIP      
  41. aundroid                      416   1911  Trust  BPIP      
  42. poptop                        409   5059  Trust  BPIP      
  43. DannyHamilton                 406  12991  Trust  BPIP      
  44. mprep                         404   5894  Trust  BPIP      
  45. Scheede                       401   2358  Trust  BPIP      
  46. romanornr                     400    678  Trust  BPIP      
  47. seoincorporation              392   3305  Trust  BPIP      
  48. aliashraf                     391   1181  Trust  BPIP      
  49. killyou72                     383   3425  Trust  BPIP      
  50. HagssFIN                      382   3287  Trust  BPIP      
  51. explorder                     378    466  Trust  BPIP      
  52. Plutosky                      377    789  Trust  BPIP      
  53. Globb0                        376   2565  Trust  BPIP      
  54. QuestionAuthority             375   9453  Trust  BPIP      
  55. deeperx                       373   1662  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  56. cAPSLOCK                      372   2655  Trust  BPIP      
  57. Paashaas                      366   1963  Trust  BPIP      
  58. sabotag3x                     362   8532  Trust  BPIP      
  59. RejectedBanana                361    384  Trust  BPIP      
  60. RHavar                        360   2194  Trust  BPIP      
  61. Saint-loup                    357   4659  Trust  BPIP      
  62. JSRAW                         345   1476  Trust  BPIP      
  63. paxmao                        344   1720  Trust  BPIP      
  64. Halab                         337    993  Trust  BPIP      
  65. AlyattesLydia                 335   1805  Trust  BPIP      
  66. gawlea                        329   1234  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  67. shasan                        327   2185  Trust  BPIP  Sig 
  68. laszlo                        325    199  Trust  BPIP      
  69. Limx Dev                      320   3359  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  70. bct_ail                       320   3633  Trust  BPIP      
  71. trantute2                     320    708  Trust  BPIP      
  72. shorena                       315  10952  Trust  BPIP      
  73. mithrim                       309    882  Trust  BPIP      
  74. kawetsriyanto                 306   1308  Trust  BPIP      
  75. tonych                        303    876  Trust  BPIP      
  76. mstfprcn                      303   1871  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  77. teeGUMES                      302    766  Trust  BPIP      
  78. jbreher                       298   6156  Trust  BPIP      
  79. arulbero                      298   1279  Trust  BPIP      
  80. Claymore                      296   2278  Trust  BPIP      
  81. crwth                         296   5018  Trust  BPIP      
  82. johhnyUA                      290   3465  Trust  BPIP      
  83. squatz1                       290   2816  Trust  BPIP      
  84. leonello                      290   1064  Trust  BPIP      
  85. Xynerise                      285    645  Trust  BPIP      
  86. duesoldi                      284   2037  Trust  BPIP      
  87. goldkingcoiner                284   1211  Trust  BPIP      
  88. Wind_FURY                     283   4463  Trust  BPIP      
  89. RichDaniel                    283    479  Trust  BPIP      
  90. 600watt                       279   5830  Trust  BPIP      
  91. dbshck                        279   2016  Trust  BPIP      
  92. asu                           279    981  Trust  BPIP      
  93. Trofo                         279   2737  Trust  BPIP      
  94. by rallier                    277   2174  Trust  BPIP      
  95. vlad230                       276    982  Trust  BPIP      
  96. NotFuzzyWarm                  275   4056  Trust  BPIP      
  97. crypmike                      273   1361  Trust  BPIP      
  98. JimboToronto                  272   6396  Trust  BPIP      
  99. BTCMILLIONAIRE                271   6149  Trust  BPIP      
 100. BitcoinTurk                   271   3142  Trust  BPIP      

[fillippone]

Can you make N high enough to show the 100 top-Merit-earning-users that I missed?

This, but for me please.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. xhomerx10                    1229   5351  Trust  BPIP      
   2. HairyMaclairy                1194   6690  Trust  BPIP      

 
Lots of WO regulars in this list.

[BitcoinGirl.Club]

4. N = 100 Altcoin discussions.

You might want to narrow it down (e.g. by date and/or post count and/or post length) since that's gonna be 2 million users. I would also suggest to exclude Bounties.

Last 120 days?

By the way one down in here. 🤪

[o_e_l_e_o]

Lots of WO regulars in this list.

Yeah, I fully expected that. As someone who no longer day trades to any meaningful extent, I generally don't have much interest in speculation, technical analysis, or the like. The few times I have ventured in to WO, I have never felt like I had much to contribute, so now I generally don't bother.

It's never seemed like somewhere that is particularly short on merits though, and if many of these "top merited users" are WO regulars then that's probably an accurate estimation on my part. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong though - would be happy to send some merits that way if you think some deserving users are going unrecognized.

[xolxol]

The list will benefit the mafia so i say no,if i would give smerits ill give to newbies who deserves it not who received merits from each other that benefits themselves.

[suchmoon]

4. N = 100 Altcoin discussions.

You might want to narrow it down (e.g. by date and/or post count and/or post length) since that's gonna be 2 million users. I would also suggest to exclude Bounties.

Last 120 days?

Ok, so based on the example:

4) Users earned less than N merits, never posted on spam boards X, Y, and Z, made at least K posts since date D.

and on your criteria, here is a top 100 list of users who earned at least one but less than 100 merits in the last 120 days, never posted in Altcoin Discussions, and never received a merit from you, sorted by post count in the last 120 days descending. Let me know if you want to adjust it in any way. I wasn't sure if you would want users who earned merits in 120 days or anyone who posted in 120 days so I went with merits since that's a narrower criteria.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. Maggiordomo                     1   7867  Trust  BPIP      
   2. korner                          1   1074  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   3. fzkto                          55   1023  Trust  BPIP      
   4. markstivn98                    11    798  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   5. bible_pay                      56    648  Trust  BPIP      
   6. WunderSchwein                  26    612  Trust  BPIP      
   7. Rooivalk                       49    608  Trust  BPIP      
   8. d_eddie                        90    462  Trust  BPIP      
   9. The0ldl_lser                   59    462  Trust  BPIP      
  10. an@sha                         55    449  Trust  BPIP      
  11. mole0815                       69    435  Trust  BPIP      
  12. investgroup                     2    432  Trust  BPIP      
  13. a7k                             1    423  Trust  BPIP      
  14. LVL F                          28    417  Trust  BPIP      
  15. rashedul74064                   1    407  Trust  BPIP      
  16. WhyFhy                         76    400  Trust  BPIP      
  17. SPQRCoin                       18    366  Trust  BPIP      
  18. offordscott                    15    364  Trust  BPIP      
  19. sabotag3x                      42    362  Trust  BPIP      
  20. F1ak                           23    356  Trust  BPIP      
  21. Smartprofit                    47    350  Trust  BPIP      
  22. cryptoamin26                    1    324  Trust  BPIP      
  23. YOBVAS                          2    317  Trust  BPIP      
  24. Ramelius                       12    316  Trust  BPIP      
  25. ugurum15                        9    314  Trust  BPIP      
  26. Tcode53                         1    310  Trust  BPIP      
  27. spider703                       1    305  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  28. efudd                          18    305  Trust  BPIP      
  29. Paolo.Demidov                  57    299  Trust  BPIP      
  30. baba0000000000                 89    297  Trust  BPIP      
  31. sam_ti_dyatel                  24    297  Trust  BPIP      
  32. my luck                         7    284  Trust  BPIP      
  33. BoozeHoundPoker                 1    281  Trust  BPIP      
  34. fxpc                            9    279  Trust  BPIP      
  35. wolwoo                         20    278  Trust  BPIP      
  36. serveria.com                   31    278  Trust  BPIP      
  37. Unknown01                      55    277  Trust  BPIP      
  38. minefarmbuy                    36    271  Trust  BPIP      
  39. kartepe                        11    268  Trust  BPIP      
  40. nezaigor                        1    265  Trust  BPIP      
  41. CrisTofar                       2    264  Trust  BPIP      
  42. reddish111                     28    263  Trust  BPIP      
  43. Shurko-1987                     1    263  Trust  BPIP      
  44. Pedro12528                      2    260  Trust  BPIP      
  45. FS2018                         33    258  Trust  BPIP      
  46. sandy-is-fine                  41    255  Trust  BPIP      
  47. doktor83                       10    253  Trust  BPIP      
  48. nadosuge                        4    252  Trust  BPIP      
  49. crypt2017                       2    248  Trust  BPIP      
  50. tayfundeniz                     3    244  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  51. tmlksck                         1    244  Trust  BPIP      
  52. Mark_R                          7    244  Trust  BPIP      
  53. Netsss                          1    242  Trust  BPIP      
  54. almaz8695                       3    241  Trust  BPIP      
  55. OneHash                         7    239  Trust  BPIP      
  56. JohnSilver                     57    234  Trust  BPIP      
  57. LordCyclone                    15    233  Trust  BPIP      
  58. thandie                        35    229  Trust  BPIP      
  59. MqMaq                           1    229  Trust  BPIP      
  60. Phil_S                         63    228  Trust  BPIP      
  61. phoen                           9    228  Trust  BPIP      
  62. gorkem19888                     3    227  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  63. Windtalker                      4    226  Trust  BPIP      
  64. janocuk                         3    225  Trust  BPIP      
  65. kropot                         18    225  Trust  BPIP      
  66. StacksNetwork                   2    224  Trust  BPIP      
  67. kriptokar                      25    224  Trust  BPIP      
  68. kukoro                          1    223  Trust  BPIP      
  69. Spokanistan51                  10    223  Trust  BPIP      
  70. NibiruHybrid                    3    222  Trust  BPIP      
  71. akgandalf                       4    220  Trust  BPIP      
  72. Azrieli                         3    219  Trust  BPIP      
  73. Aeshman                        34    218  Trust  BPIP      
  74. saddam83                        2    216  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  75. kassex                          4    210  Trust  BPIP      
  76. chipless                        1    208  Trust  BPIP      
  77. vvu351                          1    207  Trust  BPIP      
  78. AltcoinBuilder                  2    207  Trust  BPIP      
  79. dushanya                        1    207  Trust  BPIP      
  80. Gellert Grindelwald            25    204  Trust  BPIP      
  81. dwyane36                        2    202  Trust  BPIP      
  82. imamkhoi9875321                 1    200  Trust  BPIP      
  83. be.open                        65    198  Trust  BPIP      
  84. Waves.support                   3    198  Trust  BPIP      
  85. yuzuak                          8    196  Trust  BPIP      
  86. SmashDestroy                    3    196  Trust  BPIP      
  87. Prott                          18    196  Trust  BPIP      
  88. triedra                         1    195  Trust  BPIP      
  89. leonsnow                        2    195  Trust  BPIP      
  90. boltalka                        1    193  Trust  BPIP      
  91. greatbambino                    8    193  Trust  BPIP      
  92. jon1ki                          1    190  Trust  BPIP      
  93. DIKUL                          72    189  Trust  BPIP      
  94. rembit77                        3    188  Trust  BPIP      
  95. El-Cezeri                      22    188  Trust  BPIP      
  96. karakan77                       1    188  Trust  BPIP      
  97. janpotee                        4    185  Trust  BPIP      
  98. CORNEL                          2    182  Trust  BPIP      
  99. mp3.Maniac                     29    182  Trust  BPIP      
 100. CryptoMahfuz03                  1    182  Trust  BPIP      

By the way one down in here. 🤪

Thanks

[squatz1]

Not exactly sure what this is but I've seen my name come up a couple of times.

I agree. I should be merited

Hehe. Thought I would just chime in with a bit of a joke like this.

[suchmoon]

1. Users earned more than 5 merits on Development & Technical Discussion (along with it's child boards), Mining, Bitcoin Technical Support and Serious discussion, but you never merited them

I have included all child boards of Mining as well as Ivory Tower (child board of Serious Discussion). Let me know if that's not what you want.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. sidehack                      435   6349  Trust  BPIP      
   2. NotFuzzyWarm                  246   4056  Trust  BPIP      
   3. paxmao                        167   1720  Trust  BPIP      
   4. -ck                           162  11101  Trust  BPIP      
   5. vh                            152    701  Trust  BPIP      
   6. goatpig                       125   4209  Trust  BPIP      
   7. Dr.Mann                       120     40  Trust  BPIP      
   8. fanatic26_                    106    405  Trust  BPIP      
   9. tim-bc                        103    528  Trust  BPIP      
  10. OgNasty                       102   8481  Trust  BPIP      
  11. PassThePopcorn                 99    364  Trust  BPIP      
  12. dreamhouse                     88   1065  Trust  BPIP      
  13. ccgllc                         88    642  Trust  BPIP      
  14. sarcheer                       86    317  Trust  BPIP      
  15. SaltySpitoon                   81   4295  Trust  BPIP      
  16. frodocooper                    79    335  Trust  BPIP      
  17. eddie13                        77   1951  Trust  BPIP      
  18. amishmanish                    71    720  Trust  BPIP      
  19. Raymond_B                      69    521  Trust  BPIP      
  20. The Pharmacist                 68  10928  Trust  BPIP      
  21. StevenMosher                   68     74  Trust  BPIP      
  22. TheQuin                        66   5409  Trust  BPIP      
  23. mstrozier                      66     55  Trust  BPIP      
  24. thierry4wd                     63    141  Trust  BPIP      
  25. DireWolfM14                    61   1348  Trust  BPIP      
  26. guybrushthreepwood             60   3394  Trust  BPIP      
  27. Don Pedro Dinero               60   2195  Trust  BPIP      
  28. xdrpx                          58    763  Trust  BPIP      
  29. NadiaHel                       54    294  Trust  BPIP      
  30. arcmetal                       53    172  Trust  BPIP      
  31. Stryfe                         52    733  Trust  BPIP      
  32. btctrad0r                      50    317  Trust  BPIP      
  33. acarli                         48    209  Trust  BPIP      
  34. fanatic26                      46   2110  Trust  BPIP      
  35. BenOnceAgain                   46    210  Trust  BPIP      
  36. s_falahati                     45     21  Trust  BPIP      
  37. samr7                          44    163  Trust  BPIP      
  38. Foofighter                     44   1135  Trust  BPIP      
  39. Biffa                          44   2840  Trust  BPIP      
  40. gcanelson                      44    105  Trust  BPIP      
  41. Samarkand                      42   1323  Trust  BPIP      
  42. vapourminer                    41   2385  Trust  BPIP      
  43. johoe                          41    217  Trust  BPIP      
  44. ComputerGenie                  38   2561  Trust  BPIP      
  45. Shazam!!!                      37    818  Trust  BPIP      
  46. dimaze                         35    178  Trust  BPIP      
  47. stompix                        35   6639  Trust  BPIP      
  48. Baofeng                        35   2866  Trust  BPIP      
  49. puntpasskick                   35     46  Trust  BPIP      
  50. krisgt30                       33    461  Trust  BPIP      
  51. PHI1618                        33   3216  Trust  BPIP      
  52. dogie                          32   9184  Trust  BPIP      
  53. warningsigns                   32   1746  Trust  BPIP      
  54. bitperson                      32    404  Trust  BPIP      
  55. MJK_Anfaenger                  32    238  Trust  BPIP      
  56. infofront                      31   2841  Trust  BPIP      
  57. jeffthebaker                   31   1824  Trust  BPIP      
  58. 419mining                      31    144  Trust  BPIP      
  59. ryanc                          30    103  Trust  BPIP      
  60. tmfp                           30   2868  Trust  BPIP      
  61. bluefirecorp_                  30    871  Trust  BPIP      
  62. clgrissom3                     29   2956  Trust  BPIP      
  63. kenzawak                       29   5563  Trust  BPIP      
  64. Halminer                       28     25  Trust  BPIP      
  65. KonstantinosM                  27   1106  Trust  BPIP      
  66. tomywomy                       27     57  Trust  BPIP      
  67. rz66                           27     66  Trust  BPIP      
  68. dutchlincoln                   27    441  Trust  BPIP      
  69. poordeveloper                  25   2432  Trust  BPIP      
  70. Lolo54                         25     70  Trust  BPIP      
  71. Morlok8k                       25     23  Trust  BPIP      
  72. papampi                        24   1321  Trust  BPIP      
  73. TheGodson                      24    360  Trust  BPIP      
  74. mdayonliner                    24   3248  Trust  BPIP      
  75. alex1560                       24     68  Trust  BPIP      
  76. Flying Hellfish                23   2223  Trust  BPIP      
  77. selo                           23     89  Trust  BPIP      
  78. Cnut237                        23   1487  Trust  BPIP      
  79. SHBlizzard                     23    375  Trust  BPIP      
  80. ZimbaCardi                     23    106  Trust  BPIP      
  81. slush                          22   3406  Trust  BPIP      
  82. jonemil24                      22    537  Trust  BPIP      
  83. PhoenixFire                    21    251  Trust  BPIP      
  84. droark                         21    504  Trust  BPIP      
  85. cannycassiopeia                21    334  Trust  BPIP      
  86. 1miau                          21   1008  Trust  BPIP      
  87. DrHaribo                       20   3078  Trust  BPIP      
  88. philr13                        20     37  Trust  BPIP      
  89. Philopolymath                  20    540  Trust  BPIP      
  90. sqabeloth                      20     42  Trust  BPIP      
  91. escope                         20     13  Trust  BPIP      
  92. Welsh                          19   4426  Trust  BPIP      
  93. waterman                       19    195  Trust  BPIP      
  94. gt_addict                      19   2571  Trust  BPIP      
  95. rockmoney                      19    438  Trust  BPIP      
  96. cjsummers82                    19     20  Trust  BPIP      
  97. theyoungmillionaire            19    361  Trust  BPIP      
  98. HoleShot                       19     94  Trust  BPIP      
  99. John-Doe                       19   1097  Trust  BPIP      
 100. Filax                          19     23  Trust  BPIP      

[suchmoon]

2. Users earned more than 10 merits on Development & Technical Discussion (along with it's child boards), Mining, Bitcoin Technical Support and Serious discussion, but you have merited them (only for personal reference)

Same here: I have included all child boards of Mining as well as Ivory Tower (child board of Serious Discussion). Let me know if that's not what you want.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. achow101                     1387  11149  Trust  BPIP      
   2. gmaxwell                     1027   5037  Trust  BPIP      
   3. HCP                           844   6459  Trust  BPIP      
   4. bob123                        730   3813  Trust  BPIP      
   5. Coding Enthusiast             617    643  Trust  BPIP      
   6. BitCryptex                    577    984  Trust  BPIP      
   7. Carlton Banks                 549   7505  Trust  BPIP      
   8. HeRetiK                       477   2712  Trust  BPIP      
   9. philipma1957                  436  30484  Trust  BPIP      
  10. satoshi                       399    575  Trust  BPIP      
  11. nullius                       388    928  Trust  BPIP      
  12. LoyceV                        380   9282  Trust  BPIP      
  13. HagssFIN                      361   3287  Trust  BPIP      
  14. Steamtyme                     357   3035  Trust  BPIP      
  15. aliashraf                     352   1181  Trust  BPIP      
  16. o_e_l_e_o                     331   3778  Trust  BPIP      
  17. mikeywith                     326   2318  Trust  BPIP      
  18. DannyHamilton                 311  12991  Trust  BPIP      
  19. Artemis3                      311   1393  Trust  BPIP      
  20. Jet Cash                      308   6431  Trust  BPIP      
  21. pooya87                       299  11027  Trust  BPIP      
  22. TryNinja                      269   5596  Trust  BPIP      
  23. Xynerise                      266    645  Trust  BPIP      
  24. nc50lc                        238   1453  Trust  BPIP      
  25. mocacinno                     233   3161  Trust  BPIP      
  26. theymos                       231   8601  Trust  BPIP      
  27. bitmover                      215   2737  Trust  BPIP      
  28. Jean_Luc                      193    192  Trust  BPIP      
  29. nopara73                      185     42  Trust  BPIP      
  30. darosior                      165    171  Trust  BPIP      
  31. kano                          163  13561  Trust  BPIP      
  32. Macadonian                    159     72  Trust  BPIP      
  33. Abdussamad                    156   3311  Trust  BPIP      
  34. MagicByt3                     152    373  Trust  BPIP      
  35. Pmalek                        151   2244  Trust  BPIP      
  36. ranochigo                     150   5859  Trust  BPIP      
  37. Heisenberg_Hunter             150    639  Trust  BPIP      
  38. pebwindkraft                  149    259  Trust  BPIP      
  39. butka                         148    967  Trust  BPIP      
  40. Wind_FURY                     146   4463  Trust  BPIP      
  41. mixoftix                      145    104  Trust  BPIP      
  42. AverageGlabella               138    348  Trust  BPIP      
  43. odolvlobo                     136   7158  Trust  BPIP      
  44. minefarmbuy                   131   1445  Trust  BPIP      
  45. AdolfinWolf                   121   3058  Trust  BPIP      
  46. madu                          119     11  Trust  BPIP      
  47. Foxpup                        116   3551  Trust  BPIP      
  48. BitMaxz                       113   6035  Trust  BPIP      
  49. d5000                         110   5548  Trust  BPIP      
  50. aleksej996                    109   1296  Trust  BPIP      
  51. mgoz                          109    180  Trust  BPIP      
  52. DooMAD                        103   3351  Trust  BPIP      
  53. Royse777                      100   2677  Trust  BPIP      
  54. Thirdspace                     98   2322  Trust  BPIP      
  55. KingZee                        96   1030  Trust  BPIP      
  56. jackg                          95   6433  Trust  BPIP      
  57. vit05                          88   2886  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  58. friends1980                    86    861  Trust  BPIP      
  59. squatter                       85   2194  Trust  BPIP      
  60. suchmoon                       84  16819  Trust  BPIP      
  61. gentlemand                     81  16893  Trust  BPIP      
  62. starmyc                        81    195  Trust  BPIP      
  63. bones261                       78   5276  Trust  BPIP      
  64. TheArchaeologist               78    116  Trust  BPIP      
  65. arulbero                       77   1279  Trust  BPIP      
  66. DaveF                          77   1151  Trust  BPIP      
  67. Lucius                         76   4412  Trust  BPIP      
  68. NeuroticFish                   75   6168  Trust  BPIP      
  69. cellard                        75   3788  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  70. domob                          74   1066  Trust  BPIP      
  71. xtraelv                        74   1980  Trust  BPIP      
  72. CryptopreneurBrainboss         74   1449  Trust  BPIP      
  73. buwaytress                     68   6190  Trust  BPIP      
  74. hatshepsut93                   65   3630  Trust  BPIP      
  75. khaled0111                     61   1891  Trust  BPIP      
  76. LeGaulois                      59   5210  Trust  BPIP      
  77. OmegaStarScream                56   9284  Trust  BPIP      
  78. Lauda                          51  25215  Trust  BPIP      
  79. Pamoldar                       50   3878  Trust  BPIP      
  80. Raja_MBZ                       50   3709  Trust  BPIP      
  81. monsterer2                     50    349  Trust  BPIP      
  82. RHavar                         49   2194  Trust  BPIP      
  83. piotr_n                        48   2031  Trust  BPIP      
  84. djhomeschool                   47    344  Trust  BPIP      
  85. r1s2g3                         47   2117  Trust  BPIP      
  86. aplistir                       46    333  Trust  BPIP      
  87. franky1                        44  16453  Trust  BPIP      
  88. Kallisteiros                   44     85  Trust  BPIP      
  89. seoincorporation               41   3305  Trust  BPIP      
  90. danda                          40    195  Trust  BPIP      
  91. Anon136                        39   6587  Trust  BPIP      
  92. krogothmanhattan               38   6151  Trust  BPIP      
  93. hugeblack                      38   2964  Trust  BPIP      
  94. TheWolf666                     37    267  Trust  BPIP      
  95. Pieter Wuille                  36   1064  Trust  BPIP      
  96. almightyruler                  36   2428  Trust  BPIP      
  97. Shitcointalk                   36    465  Trust  BPIP      
  98. spirali                        36     65  Trust  BPIP      
  99. whotookmycrypto                36    168  Trust  BPIP      
 100. qwk                            34   6203  Trust  BPIP      

[DarkStar_]

Could I get the top ten users who have earned the most merit that I've never merited in Pilipinas and Polski? (20 total)

Thanks!

edit: Gambling (combined with Gambling discussion) as well please

[suchmoon]

Could I get the top ten users who have earned the most merit that I've never merited

Sure. Obligatory disclaimer: "Merits" column shows merits earned in the boards you requested, whereas "Posts" shows the total post count of the user.

Pilipinas

Including child boards.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. JaoBadjap                     132   1042  Trust  BPIP      
   2. Polar91                        96   3020  Trust  BPIP      
   3. ximply                         64    955  Trust  BPIP      
   4. ChardsElican28                 63    112  Trust  BPIP      
   5. Dyanggok                       60    346  Trust  BPIP      
   6. Mr. Big                        53   3303  Trust  BPIP      
   7. Nerobasta                      50    130  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   8. AdoboCandies                   44    407  Trust  BPIP      
   9. FlightyPouch                   27   3002  Trust  BPIP      
  10. eldrin                         27   1272  Trust  BPIP      

Polski

Including child boards.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. sud                            26   2520  Trust  BPIP      
   2. Clocktick                      22     44  Trust  BPIP      
   3. becometa.pl                    20     45  Trust  BPIP      
   4. maro159                        19    247  Trust  BPIP      
   5. Pilasu                         15    534  Trust  BPIP      
   6. turingox                       13     81  Trust  BPIP      
   7. caex                           12    828  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   8. ethergeek                      11     95  Trust  BPIP      
   9. FlyingAtom_Lukasz              11    133  Trust  BPIP      
  10. Gniewek89                      10     12  Trust  BPIP      

Gambling (combined with Gambling discussion)

Not including games&rounds / ponzi child boards.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. RichDaniel                    136    479  Trust  BPIP      
   2. LFC_Bitcoin                   113  13408  Trust  BPIP      
   3. stadus                        102   2959  Trust  BPIP      
   4. victorhing                    100   1339  Trust  BPIP      
   5. EnF0Rc3r                       90    120  Trust  BPIP      
   6. ethan_nx                       83    622  Trust  BPIP      
   7. CrazyCraig                     75    503  Trust  BPIP      
   8. sportsbet.io                   74   1108  Trust  BPIP      
   9. DogecoinMachine                53   2478  Trust  BPIP      
  10. harizen                        52  10110  Trust  BPIP      

[Harkorede]

Gambling (combined with Gambling discussion)

Not including games&rounds / ponzi child boards.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. RichDaniel                    136    479  Trust  BPIP      
   2. LFC_Bitcoin                   113  13408  Trust  BPIP      
   3. stadus                        102   2959  Trust  BPIP      
   4. victorhing                    100   1339  Trust  BPIP      
   5. EnF0Rc3r                       90    120  Trust  BPIP      
   6. ethan_nx                       83    622  Trust  BPIP      
   7. CrazyCraig                     75    503  Trust  BPIP      
   8. sportsbet.io                   74   1108  Trust  BPIP      
   9. DogecoinMachine                53   2478  Trust  BPIP      
  10. harizen                        52  10110  Trust  BPIP      

I think I should be on this list, maybe I'm missing one of the criteria used, but most of my merits are from Gambling Discussion

[suchmoon]

I think I should be on this list, maybe I'm missing one of the criteria used, but most of my merits are from Gambling Discussion

DarkStar_ has merited you and he's looking for users whom he never merited.

[bitmover]

Shouldn't this be in reputation?

I think that this definition "spam boards "  is bit harsh. I try to avoid some boards such as altcoin discussion by posting altcoin discussion topics in beginners and help for example, but I can't do that always. Even in spammy boards we can sometimes find good posts (like altcoin discussion and economics)

Certainly there are more quality boards such as those mentioned (technical support etc)

[DarkStar_]

I think that this definition "spam boards "  is bit harsh. I try to avoid some boards such as altcoin discussion by posting altcoin discussion topics in beginners and help for example, but I can't do that always. Even in spammy boards we can sometimes find good posts (like altcoin discussion and economics)

It's just an example by suchmoon and doesn't really mean anything. If someone wants to find people who have never posted in Altcoin Discussion for whatever reason, then so be it.

[suchmoon]

Shouldn't this be in reputation?

I think that this definition "spam boards "  is bit harsh. I try to avoid some boards such as altcoin discussion by posting altcoin discussion topics in beginners and help for example, but I can't do that always. Even in spammy boards we can sometimes find good posts (like altcoin discussion and economics)

Certainly there are more quality boards such as those mentioned (technical support etc)

This thread is about improving merit distribution and not so much about individual reputations, so I believe Meta is the place for it but if mods want to move it that's fine.

Not sure which definition you're talking about. Users can request any filters they think would help them find good content. Sure there is some good content everywhere but when resources (time or sMerits) are limited you gotta choose where to spend them.


Speaking of which, I'm still trying to come up with criteria without relying on existing merits (improving on example #4 in the OP), i.e. finding the elusive never-merited good posters. Here is what I'm thinking:

• User who made at least 50 posts in the last 6 months (just to eliminate some throw-away accounts)
• Excluding posts on Bounties and Press boards (any other completely useless boards?)
• Excluding posts shorter than 100 characters (not sure about this one)
• Has to have quoted someone at least 10 times (to show engagement in discussions and not just drive-by spamming)
• Never received merits

Any other ideas?

[DarkStar_]

Speaking of which, I'm still trying to come up with criteria without relying on existing merits (improving on example #4 in the OP), i.e. finding the elusive never-merited good posters. Here is what I'm thinking:

• User who made at least 50 posts in the last 6 months (just to eliminate some throw-away accounts)
• Excluding posts on Bounties and Press boards (any other completely useless boards?)
• Excluding posts shorter than 100 characters (not sure about this one)
• Has to have quoted someone at least 10 times (to show engagement in discussions and not just drive-by spamming)
• Never received merits

Any other ideas?

Perhaps having 90% of whatever arbitrary percentage of their posts on the first two pages of a thread? Your existing criteria would generate way too many spammers who pick a megathread in Gambling/Altcoin/Bitcoin Discussion, pick a random post to reply to and basically repeat the same points. Alternatively/additionally, exclude those who have posted in more than 7 locked threads in Gambling/Altcoin/Bitcoin Discussion since those are spam megathreads 90% of the time.

Only issue with the first part is that it would exclude people who post in various sports threads such as the Serie A discussion thread or EPL discussion thread which have valid reasons for being megathreads.

[suchmoon]

~

Good points, thank you. I'll play around with it sometime next week probably and see what I get. I don't have info on which threads are locked but maybe I can find something else to filter off spam threads.

[o_e_l_e_o]

How about minimum of 5 or 10 minutes between posts, which would help to exclude post bursters or bots having fake conversations with each other?

I would also exclude posts made on Off Topic and Archival. Maybe also exclude the marketplace boards? There are an awful lot of newbie accounts which only exist to post likely scams on the marketplace, and there are also a lot of sockpuppets created to give fake vouches to these scams.

Also exclude banned users as best you can.

[JayJuanGee]

Requesting users never merited by me who earned more than 500 merits outside of Wall Observer, sorted by merits/post, please.

I should probably ask Foxpup to give me a motorcycle or something

Sorry. Gotta fight global warming as well as shitposters.

Hahahaha

You don't like WO.

It has been my favorite thread since I came here in early 2014.  I am a little embarrassed to admit that I barely ventured out from that thread in my first couple years of forum membership.

Yeah, I agree that there is a bit of a lax merit sending practice in that thread, but if any member is actually interested in bitcoin discussion from largely a bitcoin maximalist perspective, there tends to be a decent amount of content there, too... albiet could take a decent amount of time to sort through some of the side topics, and some of the members tend to make long posts about bitcoin related matters there, too.   

[fillippone]

[...]
and some of the members tend to make long posts about bitcoin related matters there, too.    

Yeah, some do long posts...and meme posters complains a lot about those long posts. Sort of inside joke.
This is totally uncorrelated to the (usually good) content of such long posts.

[bob123]

Any other ideas?

A bit of a different request:

Can i have the top 10 people with 1000+ posts (preferably active within the last 6 months) which received the lowest amount of merits ?

[Halab]

Hi, can I ask, if it's possible, for

3) Users who earned more than 2 merits on all french boards

[asu]

Not a merit source but almost of the merits I sent were from Local Pilipinas Board.

Could I get the top ten users who have earned the most merit that I've never merited in Pilipinas?

Could I get like this also?

and
3) Users who earned more than 50 merits on Pilipinas

Thanks suchmoon

[El duderino_]

I reckon good post get completely un noticed (as https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=178336.msg51805460#msg51805460) while meme get rains of merits.

That's one of the problems with WO. You're unlikely to get merits there from non-resident wall observers ("outsiders" won't read thousands of pages) and "regulars" tend to merit rockets and mic's dinner etc. Nothing wrong with that, just a different type of environment.

The WO is just a special environment, where both good post as good memes and shared stuff can get merited, still its important to keep stuff like that in there and don't use it all over the forum.... The WO is a place where we can be a little bit human more I guess

Still good posts are not going unnoticed there but more often will get merited by WO-users, cause just like suchmoon says its to many pages to catch up if your not a daily user.

I try to mix my merit usage there and merit both good gif/meme usage as I merit good posts as I merit in support of good members to rank up a bit... Of course as I source I cannot only use my Smerits in one place and do go to other threads to send of-course ....

Though thats a hard job cause imo my source allocation is still to low, so sometimes posts will be missed cause we are just empty at that time 

Still a good post posted in the WO is always a win as its been read by many people and probably educate a lot of readers so keep them coming filippone

[suchmoon]

Can i have the top 10 people with 1000+ posts (preferably active within the last 6 months) which received the lowest amount of merits ?

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. tamango                         0   7966  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   2. niothor                         0   7024  Trust  BPIP      
   3. jdebunt                         0   6479  Trust  BPIP      
   4. favdesu                         0   5640  Trust  BPIP      
   5. GREEDYJOHN                      0   5362  Trust  BPIP      
   6. Rimidalv                        0   5345  Trust  BPIP      
   7. LastKiss                        0   5301  Trust  BPIP      
   8. Nahl                            0   5199  Trust  BPIP      
   9. goldcoinminer                   0   5126  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  10. Elize Gryanova                  0   4975  Trust  BPIP  Ban 

[fillippone]

Can i have the top 10 people with 1000+ posts (preferably active within the last 6 months) which received the lowest amount of merits ?

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. tamango                         0   7966  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   2. niothor                         0   7024  Trust  BPIP      
   3. jdebunt                         0   6479  Trust  BPIP      
   4. favdesu                         0   5640  Trust  BPIP      
   5. GREEDYJOHN                      0   5362  Trust  BPIP      
   6. Rimidalv                        0   5345  Trust  BPIP      
   7. LastKiss                        0   5301  Trust  BPIP      
   8. Nahl                            0   5199  Trust  BPIP      
   9. goldcoinminer                   0   5126  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  10. Elize Gryanova                  0   4975  Trust  BPIP  Ban 

I see what you did here.
Proof that airdropped merits were a necessity, but also very unfair to newcomers.

[suchmoon]

Users who earned more than 2 merits on all french boards

I'm including only users that you haven't merited. Let me know if that's not what you wanted.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. ludbega                       152   3782  Trust  BPIP      
   2. rouhaud                        70    888  Trust  BPIP      
   3. Aerys2                         36   2587  Trust  BPIP      
   4. alphateam                      28   1528  Trust  BPIP      
   5. Testeur1450                    21    516  Trust  BPIP      
   6. XCryptoFund                    18     44  Trust  BPIP      
   7. JollyHash                      17    829  Trust  BPIP      
   8. elma                           16    563  Trust  BPIP      
   9. gerdab                         15   1410  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  10. qemjo                          15    954  Trust  BPIP      
  11. Olishka                        15    393  Trust  BPIP      
  12. uplodex                        13     40  Trust  BPIP      
  13. ghoom2                         13    549  Trust  BPIP      
  14. ElectronLibre                  13    461  Trust  BPIP      
  15. lartiste                       12    282  Trust  BPIP      
  16. winspiral                      12   6985  Trust  BPIP      
  17. jlb94                          12    558  Trust  BPIP      
  18. cooly78                        12    869  Trust  BPIP      
  19. Lapince78190                   12    552  Trust  BPIP      
  20. linkdefeu                      11    418  Trust  BPIP      
  21. malekcap                       11    170  Trust  BPIP      
  22. Bouriffe                       11    572  Trust  BPIP      
  23. Fragan                         10     34  Trust  BPIP      
  24. pv94420                        10    370  Trust  BPIP      
  25. Delirium07                     10     88  Trust  BPIP      
  26. Saks92                         10    383  Trust  BPIP      
  27. Alexis77600                    10    101  Trust  BPIP      
  28. Nikolangeles                   10    581  Trust  BPIP      
  29. Sambah                         10    175  Trust  BPIP      
  30. henryba                        10    329  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  31. Gambit_fr                       8    506  Trust  BPIP      
  32. Bayard2018                      8    147  Trust  BPIP      
  33. Bee79                           8    253  Trust  BPIP      
  34. Hubert                          7     50  Trust  BPIP      
  35. roberto147                      7     32  Trust  BPIP      
  36. TotalPanda                      6   2511  Trust  BPIP      
  37. mikmrc                          6     47  Trust  BPIP      
  38. Spratan                         5    696  Trust  BPIP      
  39. Lisk_beginner                   5    648  Trust  BPIP      
  40. Rosam                           5    257  Trust  BPIP      
  41. loli974                         5   1028  Trust  BPIP      
  42. Corsicoin                       5    529  Trust  BPIP      
  43. easyrimka                       5   2928  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  44. Azjum                           5    462  Trust  BPIP      
  45. tomalours                       5    314  Trust  BPIP      
  46. sigri44                         5    206  Trust  BPIP      
  47. Totoff                          5    138  Trust  BPIP      
  48. without_my_moufles              5    185  Trust  BPIP      
  49. thebest67                       4    414  Trust  BPIP      
  50. joletartare                     4    777  Trust  BPIP      
  51. Appolin                         4     16  Trust  BPIP      
  52. zion73                          4     62  Trust  BPIP      
  53. haithemfar                      3    487  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  54. Robofus                         3     55  Trust  BPIP      
  55. Rico57x                         3    339  Trust  BPIP      
  56. Roxane                          3     43  Trust  BPIP      
  57. zglorg                          3   1135  Trust  BPIP      
  58. Neolysnake                      3     65  Trust  BPIP      
  59. L-titipi                        3     24  Trust  BPIP      
  60. nimiq.cafe                      3     35  Trust  BPIP      

[Halab]

I'm including only users that you haven't merited. Let me know if that's not what you wanted.

It's perfect. I was expecting a shorter list

Thx.

[cabalism13]

Could I get the top ten users who have earned the most merit that I've never merited in Pilipinas
Thanks!

Same goes for me, TIA suchmoon.


Additional TOP 10 on BEGINNERS AND HELP please.

[suchmoon]

Could I get the top ten users who have earned the most merit that I've never merited in Pilipinas?

Could I get like this also?

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. JaoBadjap                     132   1042  Trust  BPIP      
   2. Polar91                        96   3022  Trust  BPIP      
   3. ximply                         64    955  Trust  BPIP      
   4. ChardsElican28                 63    112  Trust  BPIP      
   5. Dyanggok                       60    346  Trust  BPIP      
   6. Nerobasta                      50    130  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   7. AdoboCandies                   44    407  Trust  BPIP      
   8. zenrol28                       29    852  Trust  BPIP      
   9. FlightyPouch                   27   3025  Trust  BPIP      
  10. eldrin                         27   1272  Trust  BPIP      

and
3) Users who earned more than 50 merits on Pilipinas

Since the list above already includes users with >50 merits that you didn't merit, this list will have everyone (including those that you have merited and yourself). Let me know if you meant something different.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. theyoungmillionaire           306    361  Trust  BPIP      
   2. asu                           255    986  Trust  BPIP      
   3. finaleshot2016                250   1302  Trust  BPIP      
   4. sheenshane                    182   2173  Trust  BPIP      
   5. yazher                        181    727  Trust  BPIP      
   6. JaoBadjap                     132   1042  Trust  BPIP      
   7. GreatArkansas                 123   1325  Trust  BPIP      
   8. cabalism13                    122   1661  Trust  BPIP      
   9. Polar91                        96   3022  Trust  BPIP      
  10. crwth                          90   5018  Trust  BPIP      
  11. ximply                         64    955  Trust  BPIP      
  12. ChardsElican28                 63    112  Trust  BPIP      
  13. Dyanggok                       60    346  Trust  BPIP      
  14. Mr. Big                        54   3303  Trust  BPIP      

Could I get the top ten users who have earned the most merit that I've never merited in Pilipinas
Thanks!

Same goes for me, TIA suchmoon.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. JaoBadjap                     132   1042  Trust  BPIP      
   2. Polar91                        96   3022  Trust  BPIP      
   3. ximply                         64    955  Trust  BPIP      
   4. ChardsElican28                 63    112  Trust  BPIP      
   5. Dyanggok                       60    346  Trust  BPIP      
   6. Nerobasta                      50    130  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   7. AdoboCandies                   44    407  Trust  BPIP      
   8. FlightyPouch                   27   3025  Trust  BPIP      
   9. eldrin                         27   1272  Trust  BPIP      
  10. YouShallNotPass                26    712  Trust  BPIP  Ban 

Additional TOP 10 on BEGINNERS AND HELP please.

This excludes users that you merited. Again - let me know if you had something different in mind.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. shorena                       268  10952  Trust  BPIP      
   2. pooya87                       232  11040  Trust  BPIP      
   3. iasenko                       212   2767  Trust  BPIP      
   4. logfiles                      139    630  Trust  BPIP      
   5. whotookmycrypto               134    169  Trust  BPIP      
   6. wwzsocki                      110   3500  Trust  BPIP      
   7. Sharon121212                  109    370  Trust  BPIP      
   8. mocacinno                      99   3163  Trust  BPIP      
   9. bob123                         90   3846  Trust  BPIP      
  10. OmegaStarScream                75   9292  Trust  BPIP      

[asu]

Since the list above already includes users with >50 merits that you didn't merit, this list will have everyone (including those that you have merited and yourself). Let me know if you meant something different.

...

Lovely & superb.

Only 14 i’m actually hoping it’s more than 30. It seems we need more... decent poster and as well merit circulation in our local board.

[cabalism13]

-snipped

ahm, I think there is something wrong with the given list (PILIPINAS)... I am pretty sure that some of them was already awarded by me, anyways I will just check my history later on, Thanks for this list, will also make a review on their posts later on.

[Quickseller]

Your list is inaccurate. I have 712 merit. You claim to listing everyone with merit above 435, but you clearly did not do this.

1) Users who earned more than N merits but you never merited them. N = 100 is ~700 users, N = 30 is ~2000 users.

Pamoldar has merited you.

It was unclear by his request (and in your OP) that you are excluding those who have received merit from the requestor in all cases.

In the future, please read the OP properly before trying to bash anyone you don't like..

How could you possibly say that? You literally scammed someone because you did not like the type of business they are in....

Speaking of which, I'm still trying to come up with criteria without relying on existing merits (improving on example #4 in the OP), i.e. finding the elusive never-merited good posters. Here is what I'm thinking:

• User who made at least 50 posts in the last 6 months (just to eliminate some throw-away accounts)
• Excluding posts on Bounties and Press boards (any other completely useless boards?)
• Excluding posts shorter than 100 characters (not sure about this one)
• Has to have quoted someone at least 10 times (to show engagement in discussions and not just drive-by spamming)
• Never received merits

Any other ideas?

(legitimate feedback)

I would not exclude someone from possibly giving them merit solely because they have received a single merit from you in the past. Perhaps a person should be excluded from consideration if they have received more than xx merit from you previously (possibly AND need at least yy additional merit to achieve the next rank, ignoring activity). 

I also would not give anyone merit "automatically" if they have not received merit previously. IMO a better criterion would be the person has already received x merit from y people. Anyone who does not have existing merit should IMO be reviewed and good judgement should be considered if they are putting a decent effort into their posts. There are probably enough people who have zero/1 merit who are not deserving of merit that it would probably be difficult to filter enough of them out.

To account for engagement, I would suggest that the person should be quoted by someone else. An additional sign of engagement would be that the person made a subsequent post after being quoted. To eliminate sockpuppetary, a requirement that a certain number of unique people need to quote the person (who have above a threshold of merit, possibly from a certain number of unique people).

[suchmoon]

-snipped

ahm, I think there is something wrong with the given list (PILIPINAS)... I am pretty sure that some of them was already awarded by me, anyways I will just check my history later on, Thanks for this list, will also make a review on their posts later on.

Click on the Merits number - it will open LoyceV's site with the full merit history for each user. I double-checked all 10 and you haven't sent merits to any of them

[cabalism13]

-snipped

ahm, I think there is something wrong with the given list (PILIPINAS)... I am pretty sure that some of them was already awarded by me, anyways I will just check my history later on, Thanks for this list, will also make a review on their posts later on.

Click on the Merits number - it will open LoyceV's site with the full merit history for each user. I double-checked all 10 and you haven't sent merits to any of them

You we're right, pardon me. Already checked their history, I t really seems I missed this users, I don't know why, maybe because I was to busy checking some other good posters.
Quite good enough to have a thread like this, I'm greatful for this.

Good Day!

(Now, time to spend my sMerits)


I think some of them are abusing Merit System... (Just a Hunch)

[mikeywith]

Suchmoon can I get a list of users who earned more than 50 merit on the Local Arabic board whom I haven't merited (excluding altcoins section) , and if that brings an empty list please change the number of merit earned to 10.

Thank you.

[FFrankie]

I am fairly certain you have never merited me before. But I can't easily check on my mobile device. But if you did merit me it's probably only 1 or 2 merit and I think deserve more. Lol

I would love to see that little list that is being created for me

[DarkStar_]

I am fairly certain you have never merited me before. But I can't easily check on my mobile device. But if you did merit me it's probably only 1 or 2 merit and I think deserve more. Lol

I would love to see that little list that is being created for me

Close: suchmoon merited you once and gave 4 merits.

[tranthidung]

The WO is just a special environment, where both good post as good memes and shared stuff can get merited, still its important to keep stuff like that in there and don't use it all over the forum.... The WO is a place where we can be a little bit human more I guess

People can get merits for funny posts in WO. Yes, human need to smile and funny posts serve its role to help people have funny moments. Hence, such posts deserve merits.
WO is a big thread, and within a few minutes, we can see it moves to next page(s). That thread is an unique one, we can not find other threads like this in the forum.

Still a good post posted in the WO is always a win as its been read by many people and probably educate a lot of readers so keep them coming filippone

I don't know there are posts in WO deleted due to off-topic or not. If there are screening procedures or report(s) on off-topic posts in WO, there are thousands of off-topic posts, I believe.

[Coyster]

I am fairly certain you have never merited me before. But I can't easily check on my mobile device. But if you did merit me it's probably only 1 or 2 merit and I think deserve more...

Suchmoon hardly gives less than four merits at a go , he's adopted the "4" trademark.

People can get merits for funny posts in WO. Yes, human need to smile and funny posts serve its role to help people have funny moments. Hence, such posts deserve merits.

And I do not see anything wrong with it at all, giving merits is subjective, and if a user finds a post funny, comical, interesting and whatever or however it catches their interest, giving out merits isn't wrong at all, doesn't matter the thread it is.

[Decimation]

Dammit dude, I really need to up my quality I guess. I feel bad and I'm only at 200 posts, some of these absolute legends are at 2k+ and have less than a 100 merit. I'm really trying but I just don't feel like I deserve anything after seeing how much these guys have contributed. I just need to figure out a topic I can provide some insight into that hasn't already been done...

[JayJuanGee]

Dammit dude, I really need to up my quality I guess. I feel bad and I'm only at 200 posts, some of these absolute legends are at 2k+ and have less than a 100 merit. I'm really trying but I just don't feel like I deserve anything after seeing how much these guys have contributed. I just need to figure out a topic I can provide some insight into that hasn't already been done...

You could likely provide insight to any topic that is of interest to you.  You follow such topic or even create threads on such topic, and thereby, even if there are 100s of members that know more about the topic than you, you can still provide value based on your own perspectives, opinion, view of facts and logic.  

You don't even need to recreate the wheel or create another coin or ICO in order to accomplish such.

For example, this forum has bitcoin in its name, and a whole hell of a lot of members are interested in bitcoin.  Sometimes they pump other bullshit projects in order to acquire more bitcoin, but still, in the end, they might be pumping some baloney bullshit while really understanding that bitcoin is the kingdaddy.

So, whether you are enthusiastic about bitcoin or some other coin, you don't necessarily have to discover something novel, because if you really explore your own interests and attempt to genuinely provide your own insight while attempting to be responsive to other members, likely merits would follow from that.

Finally, there should be no reason to necessarily judge other members by their number of merits, but of course, a lot of merits would likely demonstrate that the member puts a decent amount of time and thought into forum contributions - but there surely are a lot of members who might not have a lot of merits, but they also might feel that it is  NOT productive for their own use of time to spend a lot of time on the forum or their contributions.

Edit:  By the way, I just did a quickie glance at some of your recent posts, and you do seem to have a tendency to post a lot of bullshit, just short posts with hardly any substance nor analysis contained therein.  

So, yeah "upping your game" could be a beneficial thing for you, in terms of possibly inspiring other members to merit your contributions,.... not in terms of the quantity of your posts, but instead attempting to provide better quality per post that might come from reading more and attempting to actually provide content that is responsive to a member's or multiple members' concerns that you might be able to identify in the threads that you read (beyond just reading the title of the thread or whatever other random thought that comes into your mind that might of might not be relevant to any point(s) raised in the thread), if you were not seeming to bounce around so much from topic to topic in such a short period of time.  

Surely, I would not be arguing that all posts need to have high quality, but if you have a few posts of decently high quality, you might find that some members become inspired to send you an smerit or two because they gain confidence in your contributions (or abilities to contribute).. Sometimes, I will send smerits to low quality posts, while recognizing that the member has a tendency to provide decent quality and/or insights to the forum, but not necessarily good quality in the post that I am meriting.

[dkbit98]

@JayJuanGee
Any smart advices you have for me?
Fell free to inspect my profile.
I try to contribute Bitcointalk as much as I can, and as time allows it.

Thanks in advance

[suchmoon]

Suchmoon can I get a list of users who earned more than 50 merit on the Local Arabic board whom I haven't merited (excluding altcoins section) , and if that brings an empty list please change the number of merit earned to 10.

Thank you.

I apologize for taking so long with this request. My life over the last week was a reenactment of Planes, Trains & Automobiles. And buses but no bicycles. Finally got back to my home PC.

I'm assuming you meant to exclude the Arabic altcoins board. Let me know if that's not the case.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. hamade                         50    385  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   2. LBX                            28   1155  Trust  BPIP      
   3. HAKHALI                        24    323  Trust  BPIP      
   4. xlm19877                       20    312  Trust  BPIP      
   5. 7ossam7afez                    19    313  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   6. lotfiuser                      16   1114  Trust  BPIP      
   7. MiiDoViic                      15    383  Trust  BPIP      
   8. Mohammad alsmadi               15    189  Trust  BPIP      
   9. DJANAS                         11    136  Trust  BPIP      

[JayJuanGee]

@JayJuanGee
Any smart advices you have for me?
Fell free to inspect my profile.
I try to contribute Bitcointalk as much as I can, and as time allows it.

Thanks in advance

Surely there are guys here (and perhaps a gal or two, too) who are much more capable and talented than me to provide an assessment of your post history, and there are going to be a lot of personal variation too, including if you are inclined to post in languages other than English.

Sometimes posting in languages, other than English could be a useful service, but there might not be as high of a ratio of members in those sections who have  a sufficient number of smerits that they can spend.

By the way, like I tried to say in my earlier post, you are not really limited in your ability to post good content or to even receive a lot of informational value from the forum in terms of  the number  of merits that you have, but I suppose the number of merits could be ways to benefit in terms of lording over status or even some abilities to financially benefit. 

On a personal basis, I don't really ascribe a lot of self assessment based on my receiving smerits, but there is a kind of appreciation that is felt when other members send merits, even if I don't necessarily feel worth of merits in some of my posts... so the whole smerit system is a little bit of a weird dynamic that does seem to, at least, make the forum a bit better as a kind of tool to weed out some of the abilities of spam and shit posters to farm accounts and takes away some incentives to benefit from mere quantity of posts versus causing incentives to improve post quality... which any longer term member is going to appreciate when s/he has to sort through less bullshit in order to find guys (and the occasional gal or two... kind of an inside joke  ) posting content that is genuine and/or from thought through personal experiences.

Likely, I did not find your posts too repugnant because a bit over a week ago, I sent one of your posts an smerit, and that was as a result of a post in which you had pointed out some of your historical contributions to the forum, a way of seeking merit(s).

Possibly, I would not have come across your posts otherwise, because it does look like you have historically spent a decent amount of time in the bounty hunting section and also just in various altcoin sections, and those areas of the forum that are not of much interest to me and likely not too many members with smerits are going to be hanging out in those sections of the forum or wanting to spend their merits regarding those kinds of begging topics.

The suggestions that I gave to Decimation, above, were somewhat generic which means that those kinds of suggestions should be applicable to anyone, and in sum if you post in areas that are of interest to you, and you provide substantive insight regarding real issues - rather than pumping bullshit ICOs or alts, then you are more likely to build credibility over time which will likely inspire other members (including members with smerits that they can spend) to appreciate your contributions.... and get to know you, as a poster, too.

Actually, I have one more personal bias that seems to be shared by a decent number of members here, but if you spend a considerable amount of time focusing your attention on bitcoin, attempting to learn about bitcoin, looking through the whole space with bitcoin being the main game in town while other projects are frequently distinguishably less valuable than bitcoin while they are engaging in attempts to denigrate bitcoin to pump their own.. and frequently a lot of smoke and mirrors there, then you are likely going to get a decently long way to improving your own understanding of the space which will likely filter down to your getting more credibility and the respect of other forum members.  Don't get me wrong, I am not suggesting that there is completely no value that comes from altcoins, and various scam projects, but I do believe that members who attempt to focus on bitcoin and to take altcoin, ICOs, bounties or whatever with a BIG ASS grain of salt are going to more likely personally profit from their abilities to attempt to focus in that kind of way.

[dkbit98]

Thank you for much appreciated detailed review

Taking in account that my portfolio is 99% Bitcoin,
I agree with you 100% but I do play with shitcoins from time to time, I admit

[mikeywith]

I apologize for taking so long with this request.

All good , glad you are back,safe and sound.

I'm assuming you meant to exclude the Arabic altcoins board.

Yes that was exactly what i needed, I wanted to know if there is anyone who is doing just fine with merit and whom I have not merited yet,turns out that the list consists of

-banned users
-inactive users ( either inactive on the local board or the forum as a whole)

kind of what I expected since I do spend a lot of time digging for good posts to merit in the local board.

Thanks a lot SM.

[tranthidung]

Taking in account that my portfolio is 99% Bitcoin,
I agree with you 100% but I do play with shitcoins from time to time, I admit

Allocating 1% of your portfolio for shit coins will help you safe. That is for risky investment, and you won't lose your life with just 1% of your capital invest in those shit coins. If you are lucky with one or some of them, you might get richer. Someone use significant proportion of their capital for risky investment, so if you are unlucky with their chosen shitcoins, they will lose big.

[actmyname]

@suchmoon can I get a list?

Code:

Cheers :)

[The Sceptical Chymist]

Dammit dude
<snip>

Look at how much effort JayJuanGee put into his reply--and he earned merits for it.

One thing all merit seekers ought to be aware of is that regardless of how constructive your post is, if you're posting in a section that's filled with spammers who never read anything, you're not going to get those merits.  I think it's highly unlikely there are many merit sources scouring Altcoin Discussion for hidden gems.

Any smart advices you have for me?

I know you were addressing JayJuanGee, but my advice to you would be to either improve your English or hope your local board has a merit source lurking about.  There's no magic to earning merits--just take a look at some of the members who've earned the most and see what they did to get them.

[Aero Blue]

Code:

1) Users who earned more than 74 merits but you never merited them.

You just had to make it 74

Edit:

Ayy I made it

[fillippone]

<...>

Bucket List:

• Having a profile review like te one JJG made to dkbit98
  

[Decimation]

Edit:  By the way, I just did a quickie glance at some of your recent posts, and you do seem to have a tendency to post a lot of bullshit, just short posts with hardly any substance nor analysis contained therein.  

So, yeah "upping your game" could be a beneficial thing for you, in terms of possibly inspiring other members to merit your contributions,.... not in terms of the quantity of your posts, but instead attempting to provide better quality per post that might come from reading more and attempting to actually provide content that is responsive to a member's or multiple members' concerns that you might be able to identify in the threads that you read (beyond just reading the title of the thread or whatever other random thought that comes into your mind that might of might not be relevant to any point(s) raised in the thread), if you were not seeming to bounce around so much from topic to topic in such a short period of time.  

Thank you, you have motivated me to work harder and with your advice I was finally able to find a topic to post about that wasn't already done 100x over. Besides my other shit topics, I made my best one and people actually liked it. Here is the thread if you want to look, inspired by you of course. I don't want this to sound like I'm asking for merit, please DONT merit me because that's not the point. I just wanted to share how your response has affected and helped me, I hope you have a great day

[suchmoon]

Users who earned more than 74 merits but you never merited them.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. micgoossens                  2292  10806  Trust  BPIP      
   2. satoshi                      1876    575  Trust  BPIP      
   3. gmaxwell                     1337   5037  Trust  BPIP      
   4. abhiseshakana                1279   1204  Trust  BPIP      
   5. 1miau                        1232   1069  Trust  BPIP      
   6. Hhampuz                      1178   8142  Trust  BPIP      
   7. qwk                          1133   6216  Trust  BPIP      
   8. coinlocket$                  1045   4704  Trust  BPIP      
   9. Steamtyme                    1028   3078  Trust  BPIP      
  10. roycilik                      973   1992  Trust  BPIP      
  11. BobLawblaw                    971   4420  Trust  BPIP      
  12. LFC_Bitcoin                   948  13567  Trust  BPIP      
  13. Toxic2040                     933   2120  Trust  BPIP      
  14. ETFbitcoin                    924   2850  Trust  BPIP      
  15. theyoungmillionaire           917    363  Trust  BPIP      
  16. bitmover                      905   2869  Trust  BPIP      
  17. mu_enrico                     888   1340  Trust  BPIP      
  18. BitCryptex                    883   1068  Trust  BPIP      
  19. gentlemand                    857  17062  Trust  BPIP      
  20. kenzawak                      839   5571  Trust  BPIP      
  21. Husna QA                      832    955  Trust  BPIP      
  22. philipma1957                  824  30624  Trust  BPIP      
  23. jojo69                        800   6742  Trust  BPIP      
  24. Carlton Banks                 790   7528  Trust  BPIP      
  25. PHI1618                       787   3242  Trust  BPIP      
  26. fillippone                    787   1522  Trust  BPIP      
  27. taikuri13                     783   2304  Trust  BPIP      
  28. pooya87                       779  11143  Trust  BPIP      
  29. pandukelana2712               754    888  Trust  BPIP      
  30. Veleor                        748   1419  Trust  BPIP      
  31. Coolcryptovator               748   3104  Trust  BPIP      
  32. VB1001                        747   1770  Trust  BPIP      
  33. Coding Enthusiast             695    653  Trust  BPIP      
  34. bones261                      670   5330  Trust  BPIP      
  35. Goran_                        667   4028  Trust  BPIP      
  36. mocacinno                     654   3189  Trust  BPIP      
  37. mole0815                      643   2599  Trust  BPIP      
  38. Pmalek                        619   2332  Trust  BPIP      
  39. witcher_sense                 601   1191  Trust  BPIP      
  40. Artemis3                      582   1517  Trust  BPIP      
  41. wwzsocki                      557   3542  Trust  BPIP      
  42. lovesmayfamilis               551   1045  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  43. stompix                       550   6693  Trust  BPIP      
  44. chimk                         542   3296  Trust  BPIP      
  45. d_eddie                       539   2253  Trust  BPIP      
  46. GameKyuubi                    535    251  Trust  BPIP      
  47. Matthias9515                  534   2337  Trust  BPIP      
  48. d5000                         527   5570  Trust  BPIP      
  49. bill gator                    526   2964  Trust  BPIP      
  50. Coin-1                        520   2033  Trust  BPIP      
  51. Hal                           519    314  Trust  BPIP      
  52. bitserve                      515   4655  Trust  BPIP      
  53. tvplus006                     515   1028  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  54. BitcoinPenny                  508   2031  Trust  BPIP      
  55. sncc                          508    535  Trust  BPIP      
  56. cabalism13                    508   1735  Trust  BPIP      
  57. Torque                        506   5144  Trust  BPIP      
  58. Smart man                     504   1134  Trust  BPIP      
  59. mjglqw                        495   6156  Trust  BPIP      
  60. cryptovigi                    483   1214  Trust  BPIP      
  61. zazarb                        482   7328  Trust  BPIP  Sig 
  62. TheFuzzStone                  480   2136  Trust  BPIP      
  63. AdolfinWolf                   479   3155  Trust  BPIP      
  64. pitipawn                      478    563  Trust  BPIP      
  65. Heisenberg_Hunter             476    670  Trust  BPIP      
  66. mindrust                      474   5305  Trust  BPIP      
  67. BTCforJoe                     473   2587  Trust  BPIP      
  68. Welsh                         470   4455  Trust  BPIP      
  69. nullCoiner                    458   3825  Trust  BPIP      
  70. poptop                        456   5097  Trust  BPIP      
  71. sidehack                      454   6353  Trust  BPIP      
  72. seoincorporation              440   3389  Trust  BPIP      
  73. Elwar                         439  10476  Trust  BPIP      
  74. xenon131                      439    905  Trust  BPIP      
  75. igor72                        438    891  Trust  BPIP      
  76. ryzaadit                      431   1585  Trust  BPIP      
  77. anonymousminer                429   1702  Trust  BPIP      
  78. Scheede                       425   2390  Trust  BPIP      
  79. vit05                         424   2884  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  80. buwaytress                    423   6297  Trust  BPIP      
  81. aundroid                      421   1953  Trust  BPIP      
  82. Plutosky                      418    813  Trust  BPIP      
  83. DannyHamilton                 414  12988  Trust  BPIP      
  84. Tytanowy Janusz               411   1179  Trust  BPIP      
  85. romanornr                     400    678  Trust  BPIP      
  86. aliashraf                     394   1193  Trust  BPIP      
  87. HagssFIN                      390   3300  Trust  BPIP      
  88. OmegaStarScream               388   9332  Trust  BPIP      
  89. Raja_MBZ                      388   3783  Trust  BPIP      
  90. r1s2g3                        387   2126  Trust  BPIP      
  91. madnessteat                   381   1152  Trust  BPIP      
  92. JSRAW                         380   1574  Trust  BPIP      
  93. explorder                     378    466  Trust  BPIP      
  94. Saint-loup                    377   4860  Trust  BPIP      
  95. QuestionAuthority             375   9453  Trust  BPIP      
  96. deeperx                       374   1675  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  97. cAPSLOCK                      373   2660  Trust  BPIP      
  98. Paashaas                      367   1968  Trust  BPIP      
  99. odolvlobo                     366   7192  Trust  BPIP      
 100. RejectedBanana                365    387  Trust  BPIP      

[CucakRowo]

-snip-

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban  
  42. lovesmayfamilis               551   1045  Trust  BPIP  Ban 

lovesmayfamilis is not banned anymore.
https://bpip.org/search.aspx?q=lovesmayfamilis
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5141782.msg51061094#msg51061094

[suchmoon]

lovesmayfamilis is not banned anymore

I know. Unfortunately I don't have a way to track unbans. So threat the "Ban" note as "Had been permanently banned at some point".

[tbct_mt2]

I know. Unfortunately I don't have a way to track unbans. So threat the "Ban" note as "Had been permanently banned at some point".

As I know, LoyceV has his technical steps to do this. You can ask him for help. If I am remember correctly, LoyceV use the trick to follow when a permanent banned user come back to post. I am not sure, but I think this is what LoyceV disclosed in one of his threads on banned users.

[LoyceV]

I know. Unfortunately I don't have a way to track unbans. So threat the "Ban" note as "Had been permanently banned at some point".

As I know, LoyceV has his technical steps to do this. You can ask him for help. If I am remember correctly, LoyceV use the trick to follow when a permanent banned user come back to post.

Correct. When a user posts again, I remove him from my list of banned users (see details).

@suchmoon: if you use the daily update from [ LIST] Banned users, you've covered most unbans already.

[suchmoon]

Can I get this lists (For Beginners&Help and Pilipinas Sections Only)

Users with 9 Merits with less than 60 activities

And

Users with 95-99 Merits and 240-249 Merits

I'm guessing you want users with those amounts of total merits so that you could help them rank up, and they should have posted in those two boards. How much should the users have posted in B&H and Pilipinas to get included in the list? I used a threshold of at least once in the last 365 days. Let me know if you want me to adjust that but as you can see there aren't that many such users.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. GrosWesh                      244   1439  Trust  BPIP      
   2. Instely                         9     91  Trust  BPIP      

[suchmoon]

I've been mucking around with this on and off for a couple of months - trying to get a list of unmerited and undermerited users who might deserve some merits - and I think all I got is a lot of material for the wall of shame thread

Here is my step-by-step progress of an attempt to narrow the list: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5185946

At the top of each post there is an explanation what I was doing. Eventually I got to this list of 525 "candidates": https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5185946.msg52498875#msg52498875

On of the biggest problems is that at this point the "Posts" column still links to their entire post histories and there is no easy way to review just the posts that passed my filters so it's not even clear if those filters are worth anything. Spot checking a few users was not encouraging. Generic meaningless tripe and broken English to the point of being incomprehensible seem to be the most common issues.

#1 on the list (user has 2 earned merits):

I don't remember how much I losses in gambling because if I did that, it would make me sad, and I will try to recover the losses. That will be difficult for me because I don't have good luck in the gambling games. And if I try it with so hard, I will only get more losses, and I realize that will makes I broke. I am trying to playing gambling, but I don't use so much money because of the big risk in gambling, and I try to accept the risk.

#65 on the list (user has 0 earned merits, seems to be a shitcoin ladder-bumper):

Hope the dev will always update information about their process, but to list the exchanger is not easy
Exchangers will certainly see whether the project of the coin can compete in their exchanger or not

#149 on the list (user has 1 earned merit):

With more new applications that were getting developed it is possible to make cryptocurrency and bitcoin user friendly to all levels of people. With beginners too it isn't that difficult, because if they make a transaction once they'll get to know good about it. Further on using bitcoin for few times they'll more comfortable using it further.

#305 on the list (user has 2 earned merits):

You got a point there but in my view its too late for the government of the united state of America to gain control over the cryptocurrency industry. They have been hash on the community, hash on their citizens for using cryptocurrency, they don't want to use decentralized exchanges around her territory, these sum up among others will not give them the enably environment to control the industry.
There have been speculations that they are likely to be the inventors of cryptocurrency, but until then, if they aren't the ones then they cannot control the cryptocurrency.

#494 on the list (user has 0 earned merits):

If you are good at mining, you can do it. Mining hasn't permission for all country. Research won't lose your any time and money. New coin is coming for future market, you should research on new coin. My prefer is trading with top altcoins.

Could there be some gold in that pile of poo? I'm not too hopeful. I'll keep tweaking my search when I have some time but so far I think I'm better off just opening a few threads and reading them... even on some really shitty boards like Altcoin Discussion I can usually find a post or two that are not entirely horrible and send them a few encouragement merits.

[o_e_l_e_o]

Could there be some gold in that pile of poo? I'm not too hopeful.

I also spent some time checking the top few users and found nothing of interest. I figured maybe they were the spammers who had managed to squeeze through all your filters, so I jumped to the bottom and checked out the last few users with the lowest post counts. Results were similarly discouraging. I couldn't find anything worth meriting in about 20 minutes of looking, so I just merited you instead for the effort. I'll take a longer look another time, but I'm not hopeful.

This seems to be another data point (along with Loyce's Report to Merit Sources thread) to disprove the oft repeated claim that there are a plethora of great posts and great users who are going under merited.

[legendster]

Hi Loyce. Suchmoon

Can I get a list of users that :

>Have posted at least 10 posts in the Indian board (including any of its child board) in the last 6 months

>Have never been merited by Suchmoon, Foxup, or Legendster (me)

>Have posted at least 29+ posts in the last 30 days

-

The intent is to find deserving people in the Indian section that have not been noticed yet.
Thanks in advance.

[LoyceV]

Hi Loyce.

Hi

Can I get a list of users that :

>Have posted at least 10 posts in the Indian board (including any of its child board) in the last 6 months

This is suchmoon's thread, not mine, but your request would require scraping many posts on those boards.

[legendster]

Hi Loyce.

Hi

Can I get a list of users that :

>Have posted at least 10 posts in the Indian board (including any of its child board) in the last 6 months

This is suchmoon's thread, not mine, but your request would require scraping many posts on those boards.

I am sorry you two look so alike.

I know its a long-running joke but I am not even kidding.

I messaged you about the issue.

[suchmoon]

I don't know if this is the right thread, but will still leave my request here:

Users who lacks 5-10 Merits to rank up @ Pilipinas Local Board

From Full Member and up. Including Member rank would basically include everyone with 0 merits so not feasible. I'm also not looking if they lack activity to rank up - just looking at merits.

That is, users with 90-95, 240-245, 490-495, and 990-995 merits, who posted on the Pilipinas boards at least once in the last 365 days:

no such users

And just in case you meant anybody who lacks at least one merit - users with 90-99, 240-249, 490-499, and 990-999 merits, who posted on the Pilipinas boards at least once in the last 365 days:

no such users

Jr. Members with 0 Merits and less than 120 activities (Pilipinas)

no such users

(a Jr. Member by definition needs to have at least one merit)

Newbies and Jr Members with 10+ Merits that didn't receive any from me (Pilipinas) <--edited

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. blink                          21     16  Trust  BPIP      
   2. Zener Diode                    12     22  Trust  BPIP      

Newbies with 0 Merits and less than 100 activities (Pilipinas)

... who posted on the Pilipinas boards at least once in the last 365 days (top 100 by number of posts):

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. herasandraferrer                0    255  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   2. abnosial                        0    112  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   3. Gianilf                         0     97  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   4. shishi-icy                      0     95  Trust  BPIP      
   5. darkdangem                      0     92  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   6. CLOCKWERK                       0     92  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   7. Ems439                          0     89  Trust  BPIP      
   8. yhanrose19                      0     88  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   9. stevenwin19991                  0     84  Trust  BPIP      
  10. rockzu07                        0     82  Trust  BPIP      
  11. Dagol                           0     78  Trust  BPIP      
  12. marvin17                        0     78  Trust  BPIP      
  13. Aljon15                         0     74  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  14. leandro996                      0     73  Trust  BPIP      
  15. sam.purg                        0     69  Trust  BPIP      
  16. BitEnergi                       0     68  Trust  BPIP      
  17. xevera                          0     68  Trust  BPIP      
  18. ALLON2017                       0     68  Trust  BPIP      
  19. coins.ph.Julze                  0     68  Trust  BPIP      
  20. TradingIsBreath                 0     67  Trust  BPIP      
  21. boboto                          0     66  Trust  BPIP      
  22. Nolivelasco13                   0     65  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  23. jannahchua26                    0     65  Trust  BPIP      
  24. rajeshkpucsd                    0     64  Trust  BPIP      
  25. warcrydr3                       0     64  Trust  BPIP      
  26. nhoyasim101                     0     63  Trust  BPIP      
  27. doraemon26                      0     63  Trust  BPIP      
  28. PrimeBitExchange                0     62  Trust  BPIP      
  29. BlinkInDie                      0     62  Trust  BPIP      
  30. papanipapi                      0     61  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  31. VinsmokeSanji                   0     61  Trust  BPIP      
  32. Boardmangetpaid                 0     61  Trust  BPIP      
  33. redandroid                      0     60  Trust  BPIP      
  34. riddy09                         0     59  Trust  BPIP      
  35. jinggelbelz                     0     58  Trust  BPIP      
  36. Cleeannetuz                     0     57  Trust  BPIP      
  37. HankMobley                      0     56  Trust  BPIP      
  38. Ganthet                         0     55  Trust  BPIP      
  39. bitcoingamer8                   0     55  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  40. jsquad                          0     53  Trust  BPIP      
  41. frankydoodle01                  0     52  Trust  BPIP      
  42. mrbean222                       0     52  Trust  BPIP      
  43. Babes02                         0     50  Trust  BPIP      
  44. sonypower                       0     49  Trust  BPIP      
  45. Mr.frost                        0     49  Trust  BPIP      
  46. jaysonguild                     0     49  Trust  BPIP      
  47. Trililing                       0     49  Trust  BPIP      
  48. zeto                            0     48  Trust  BPIP      
  49. Bulol                           0     48  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  50. jlalunz                         0     47  Trust  BPIP      
  51. moonchaser_babylove28           0     47  Trust  BPIP      
  52. OnlineMoney                     0     46  Trust  BPIP      
  53. lDEATHl                         0     45  Trust  BPIP      
  54. trish22                         0     44  Trust  BPIP      
  55. Japorms                         0     44  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  56. Purobantakte                    0     44  Trust  BPIP      
  57. BillGoldberg                    0     42  Trust  BPIP      
  58. Menerever                       0     41  Trust  BPIP      
  59. xenizero                        0     41  Trust  BPIP      
  60. re-captchaz                     0     41  Trust  BPIP      
  61. jhunsantiago                    0     40  Trust  BPIP      
  62. camsjennerzxc                   0     40  Trust  BPIP      
  63. Rock and Paper                  0     39  Trust  BPIP      
  64. Jevslasher                      0     39  Trust  BPIP      
  65. al0729                          0     38  Trust  BPIP      
  66. Jhet09                          0     38  Trust  BPIP      
  67. Mcalexander016                  0     37  Trust  BPIP      
  68. SergeyKZ                        0     37  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  69. ernitetur                       0     36  Trust  BPIP      
  70. cryp2poseidon                   0     36  Trust  BPIP      
  71. Biribiri                        0     36  Trust  BPIP      
  72. faithparungao24btt              0     35  Trust  BPIP      
  73. leicasela                       0     35  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  74. jhayaims                        0     34  Trust  BPIP      
  75. cin.exception                   0     34  Trust  BPIP      
  76. AirdropDailyUpdates             0     33  Trust  BPIP      
  77. andrei18                        0     33  Trust  BPIP      
  78. snaptrck                        0     32  Trust  BPIP      
  79. iNhicz26                        0     32  Trust  BPIP      
  80. 90nairdla                       0     31  Trust  BPIP      
  81. bluerain25                      0     31  Trust  BPIP      
  82. crypto.bin101                   0     30  Trust  BPIP      
  83. kimmy28                         0     29  Trust  BPIP      
  84. nganga                          0     28  Trust  BPIP      
  85. cryptoquiin                     0     28  Trust  BPIP      
  86. metalizerbux                    0     28  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
  87. merlyn02                        0     27  Trust  BPIP      
  88. lola100                         0     27  Trust  BPIP      
  89. skyrior1                        0     26  Trust  BPIP      
  90. registered                      0     25  Trust  BPIP      
  91. DragonSlayer2018                0     25  Trust  BPIP      
  92. Mark Anthony Castor             0     25  Trust  BPIP      
  93. litro02                         0     24  Trust  BPIP      
  94. Ferdinand011                    0     24  Trust  BPIP      
  95. tentan                          0     24  Trust  BPIP      
  96. CalliBabe                       0     24  Trust  BPIP      
  97. freeze2012                      0     23  Trust  BPIP      
  98. gleisson05                      0     23  Trust  BPIP      
  99. Tamayan                         0     23  Trust  BPIP      
 100. Jhony31                         0     23  Trust  BPIP      

[cabalism13]

...

So in short, I haven't missed a good user until now 🤣 Thanks suchmoon (I thought you liked the name given by the vixen, I guess I'm just hallucinating LoL)

[suchmoon]

>Have posted at least 10 posts in the Indian board (including any of its child board) in the last 6 months

>Have never been merited by Suchmoon, Foxup, or Legendster (me)

>Have posted at least 29+ posts in the last 30 days

Includes only users who have earned merits. If you want all users (including ones with no merits) - let me know. Might be a long list though.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. eaLiTy                         40   3643  Trust  BPIP      
   2. akram143                       12   2355  Trust  BPIP      
   3. libert19                       10   3070  Trust  BPIP